Saturday, April 17, 2010

If Kentucky had charters, which rules would they ask to have waived?

Jack Brammer blogs about what might be discussed in a special session to get us a state budget:
Williams, R-Burkesville, also said he would like to see Gov. Steve Beshear include on the call for a special session creation of charter schools to improve Kentucky’s chances of obtaining more federal funds. Such schools receive public money but are free of some rules that apply to other public schools in exchange for some type of accountability for producing certain results.
That second sentence is a fine definition of charter schools elsewhere.

But after twenty years of working with Kentucky school law,  I'm perplexed:  Which of our "rules that apply to other public schools" would a charter-organizer want us to waive?

For example, we don't have requirements about how much time students spend on particular subjects.  We have rules about class size--but they only apply to schools without school councils, and we have very few of those around.

Elsewhere,  states and districts can decide that all their schools must use a particular curriculum or teaching strategy.  Here, with school-based decision making, that sort of rule can only come from within the school's own leadership.

And then, there's an important list of rules that current schools follow and that charter schools would also have to follow.  Rules about safety, health, and adequate facilities will still applu, and so will rules about services to students with disabilities.  Under the charter legislation that passed the Kentucky Senate, charters would also have to have standards as high or higher than our new state standards and assessments to show the standards being met.  In the same bill, the educators would need Kentucky certification and they'd need to pay into the Kentucky teachers retirement system.

So what might a charter ask to waive?  I've thought of a few possibilities, including the requirements that schools:
  • provide 175 six-hour instructional days or the equivalent 1,050 hours.
  • offer added instructional time for students who need it, also known as extended school services.
  • identify and provide differentiated services to gifted and talented students. 
  • make college-level courses available to high school students.
There are also some "terms and conditions of employment" that might not apply, including uniform salary schedules, continuing contracts (also known as "tenure"), and the cycle of evaluations and professional development support.

Frankly, though, I'm hard put to see any of those rules as being enough trouble to warrant the huge effort needed to create a new school from scratch.

In the end, I believe the real constraints on Kentucky school innovations come not from an external "them" but from each school's internal "us."  That is, when one or two people in a school are excited by a new way of doing things, they may not be able to energize enough other people in the same building.  Absent a consensus on the school council and something close to consensus in the staff as a whole, the individual enthusiasm never flowers into schoolwide change.  For any given person who wants a bold initiative, the main barrier isn't the mandates coming from officials in Frankfort or authorities in the district central office, but the inability to convince friends and colleagues in adjacent classrooms.

Accordingly, I think the main appeal of starting a Kentucky charter school would be the ability to break out of  that collegial log-jam. Instead of continuing to woo those who don't want to try a new approach--Core Knowledge, Success for All, Montessori, Paedeia, you name it--the two or three or five who want to try that method could pull away, find half a dozen more colleagues interested in the same approach, and start recruiting parents who also want to give something different a try.  Or, the other way around, parents who want a particular distinctive model could start recruiting teachers who find the same idea exciting.

Friday, April 16, 2010

A constitutional right to clogging? I can make that case!

Our constitution requires an efficient system of common schools. The Rose opinion filled in that requirement by saying such a system must "have as its goal to provide each and every child with at least the seven following capacities," and adding a list that includes "sufficient grounding in the arts to enable each student to appreciate his or her cultural and historical heritage." Here's the Celtic heritage of the Southern Highlands, and I'd happily argue that every Kentucky child is entitled to a generous helping of it.


Thursday, April 15, 2010

The giant text complexity challenge inside the new literacy standards

While reading demands in college, workforce training programs, and life in general have held steady or increased over the last half century, K–12 texts and reading tasks have actually declined in sophistication, leaving a serious gap between many high school seniors’ reading ability and the reading requirements they face after graduation.
That's from the draft Common Core Standards for English Language Arts and Literacy in History/Social Studies & Science, and more exactly from "Appendix A: Research Supporting Key Elements of the Standards."

To back up that important claim, the Appendix shares evidence from studies showing that:
  • Students who fall short of ACT's college readiness benchmarks have the greatest difficulty with the test items involving the most complex text.
  • K-12 reading assignments have become much less demanding in the last half-century, with an especially large drop-off in high school expectations.
  • College reading assignments have moved in the opposite direction, becoming a bit harder over the same fifty years.
  • High school teachers commonly give  students many kinds of support and coaching to help them figure out the material, but college teachers expect students to pull the knowledge from the text on their own, making the gap in practical ability even wider than the gap in the texts themselves.
Here's a single stunning sentence to remember:
Gary L. Williamson in 2004 found a 350L (Lexile) gap between the difficulty of end-of-high school and college texts—a gap equivalent to 1.5 standard deviations and more than the Lexile difference between grade 4 and grade 8 texts on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). 
(Lexiles are a measure of reading difficulty, respected by educators I count on for insight and explained in further detail here.)

The draft standards aim to close that reading gap, with every grade aiming higher and the cumulative effect being teaching that equips every student to handle college-level complex text independently before graduation.

The draft pushes for that result in multiple ways.  For example:
  • Bar graphs for each grade show the proportion of student reading that should be at grade level andthe proportion that should push past that point to keep building stronger skills.  
  • "Exemplar" texts illustrate the kind of work students should be reading in each grade: schools don't need to use those exact books but will need to use material at least as challenging.
  • Though literary reading is still valued, explanatory and persuasive text gets heavy new emphasis--because those are the kinds of text most used in college and in modern workplaces.
  • Literacy in science and social studies gets direct attention for grades 6 through 12, as well as a place in the document title, pushing for coursework that builds background knowledge and systematic experience making sense of complex reading material in those fields.
I'm convinced: our students (and therefore our teachers) must rise to this new level of literacy expectation.  As we move into that effort, it is important to know that the bar is being raised far higher, and reaching that bar will be a major challenge of the coming years.

Sources: both the draft Standards and the research Appendix can be downloaded here.  Final editions are scheduled to be available in late May.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Giant Steps April Edition (SB 1, Common Core, and RTTT)


I've updated our one-page summary of Senate Bill 1, Common Core Standards, and Race to the Top.

The key new information is that Kentucky will be competing for the RTTT money in the second round. and that the math and reading standards are now scheduled to be finalized late this spring.

Otherwise, it's similar to the text we shared in late March, so I won't make the whole text into a blog post.   If you'd like the newest edition,  click here to download the PDF.

Moving the standards into classroom use: Kentucky's "Big Ask"

At Monday's "Unbridled Learning Summit," the Department launched its new model for equipping teachers to deliver on Kentucky's new standards.   Here are the main ideas:
  1. Regional networks, one set for mathematics and another for English/language arts, will include several teachers sent by each district.
  2. Superintendents, principals, and instructional supervisors will participate in separate, but related networks.
  3. Overall, network participants will make a three-year commitment to eight meeting days a year, plus study before meetings and on-line discussion between meetings.
  4. All the networks will study a sequence of core issues: how to break down the new standards, develop classroom assessments, and organize instruction to move all students to college-and-career-readiness.
  5. Over the same three years, the network participants from each district will design and implement the district effort to move those same practices into district-wide classroom application.
This is a giant initiative.  Somewhere between two and three thousand people will participate in the networks, and they'll be aiming to change the classroom practice of more than 40,000 teachers and the academic achievement of more than 600,000 students.

If Kentucky gets a Race to the Top grant in September, districts will have new money for substitutes, stipends, travel, and other costs of this work.

If Race to the Top does not happen for Kentucky, the Department is still asking them to commit to the effort, finding the resources anywhere they can.

I'm proud of the commitment that says we will go forward in spite of a terrible recession, whether the federal government sends us help or not.   Our students need to reach the new standards, and building local capacity is the best way to make that happen.  The summit began with Commissioner Holliday, Bob King of the Council on Postsecondary Education, Phil Rogers of the Professional Standards Board, Chris Minnich from the Council of Chief State School Officers, and Governor Steve Beshear all laying out how important this effort will be.  This is the right work, and getting it done is the right step forward.

I'm proud of all the district leaders at the summit who immediately began figuring out how they will make the effort succeed.

I'm confident that, in years to come, we'll all be proud of the energy that will go into this work and the growth for students that will come out of it.

And yet, just for a minute, we need to notice that what we're asking of teachers and leaders in our school systems is huge if RTTT comes through, and doubly huge if it doesn't.

I believe Kentucky educators will rise to the challenge and get the work done. As a parent and a citizen, I think it's important for my first responses to be "Wow!" and "Thank you!"

Monday, April 12, 2010

Small good news: March state revenue met expectations

This terrible recession may be starting to loosen its grip--while still being pretty terrible.

For March 2010, state General Fund revenue was higher than March 2009, and that's good news.

That's not huge good news.  For the full fiscal year (counting from last July 1), this year's revenue is still far behind last year's.

However,  a month with growth is better than continued decline.

Also, the March growth means we're on-track to meet the most recent revenue estimate.  If that continues, we won't see any more cuts to this year's funding for education and other government efforts.

Source: the March Tax Receipt Report from the Office of State Budget Development, here.

Friday, April 9, 2010

In low-performing schools, who chooses the intervention? (Caverna wants to know)

Under a new law and a new regulation passed in January, Caverna High School and a handful of other schools have been identified as  persistently low performing.  That makes each one eligible for a major school improvement grant but required to implement one of four intervention options:
  • External management, where an outside organization takes over day-to-day management.
  • Restaffing, where the principal and at least half the staff are replaced and a research-based action plan is implemented.
  • School closure, where  all students transfer to other district schools (not an option in Caverna).
  • Transformation, where the principal is replaced and "an extensive set of specified strategies" are implemented to turn the school around.
The Glasgow Daily Times reports today that the district is still waiting to hear the audit results and the intervention approach.  Caverna Superintendent Sam Dick shared a number of questions and frustrations, including this one:
One of the questions Dick had for the academic team was who chooses the intervention model.

“The team, when it was here, said it did. The commissioner, when I talked to him, said he did. The legislators, when I talked to them, said the statute said I did and somebody else said it was the site-based council,” Dick said. “So we really don’t know who gets to pick the intervention model.”
That's the sort of question that should definitely have an answer in the official rules.  I pulled up the new state regulation, 703 KAR 5:180, and found Section 5, entitled "Authority to Select an Intervention Option."

Based on the regulation, the answer depends on the results of the recent audits.  Both the school and the district leadership have been audited, checking to see if leaders at each level have the capacity to lead the transformation.  The audit may find the school weak and the district strong, the school strong and the district weak, or both weak, or both strong.  Based on those audit findings, different people decide which kind of intervention will be used at the school:
In other words, until the audit results are in, there's no way to say who will be making the big decision on next steps.

Seeing that SEEK decline (and the shifting state and local shares)

The Council for Better Education has just released new reports showing SEEK trends over the last five years.  Reports for the state and each district are available here, and the press release is here. 

Statewide, total SEEK funding per pupil showed small growth each year until this one.  Remember that in 2008, districts were also required to add two instructional days, explaining the largest of the earlier increases.  For 2010, the total moved downward:


The drop was created by shrinking state contributions.  The state's share of the SEEK base guarantee went down in 2009 and down again in 2010.  The state contribution to Tier I equalization went down in 2010, and the add-on funding for students with special needs also dipped this year.

Meanwhile, local funding has grown.  Until 2010, the local growth was enough to offset the state shifts.  In 2010, local growth slowed down substantially, adding only $27 per pupil to the required SEEK base, $2 to optional Tier I funding that receives state equalization, and $2 to unequalized Tier II funding.
Do notice that the largest growth has been in the unequalized Tier II portion.  "Unequalized" means that two districts can set identical tax rates, but because they have different levels of taxable property, one will receive far more revenue than the other from that taxation.  Between districts, funding from Tier II is guaranteed to be unequal, reflecting geography and wealth rather than student needs.

Repeating the earlier disclosure, I consult for the Council and contributed to the development of these reports.

SEEK funding already declining statewide, with next year's budget possibly cutting more

The Council for Better Education has just released a statement and a set of reports:

STATEWIDE SCHOOL FUNDING DECLINE RAISES CONCERNS
(OWENSBORO, Ky.) Kentucky schools received less money per pupil from the state’s main funding formula this year. Schools are getting $50 less per pupil in state SEEK funding for 2009-10 than they received the year before. Even with a $31 increase in average local funding, schools still have $19 less per student. The Council for Better Education (Council) finds the trend alarming and urges the General Assembly to restore SEEK funding in the new state budget.

SEEK is short for “Support Education Excellence in Kentucky,” the program that provides most of the dollars schools use to educate students from kindergarten through high school. SEEK includes both state and local dollars. The Council, which represents local districts in work on education quality and funding, released a new overview this week of SEEK trends from 2005-06 through 2009-10.

“In years past, we’ve seen meager increases in state SEEK, sometimes keeping up with inflation and sometimes not even doing that. This year is different. This year, state SEEK funding actually declined,” said Tom Shelton, the Daviess County school superintendent who serves as council president.

Factoring in inflation makes the problem even clearer. “If you adjust for rising costs, both state and local dollars lost buying power. Effectively, schools have $211 less per pupil to work with this year than they did last year,” Shelton pointed out.

Shelton sees these results as especially important in the last days of the General Assembly. “The state budget is being set right now. The House is talking about reducing the state share of SEEK funding again, and the Senate is talking about reducing it even more. That’s hard to understand. Our students need legislators to take a clear-eyed look at the harm that’s already been done, stop the SEEK cuts, and add the funding our schools need to equip all students for adult success.”

In addition to the statewide report, the Council has prepared overviews for each Kentucky school district, showing SEEK funding for the last five years both with and without inflation adjustments. The Council’s website, www.kycbe.com, offers easy access to the state and all the local versions of the two-page reports.

The Council for Better Education represents 168 of Kentucky’s 174 school districts in efforts to ensure full implementation of Kentucky’s constitutional commitment to our students and our common schools.

###
Disclosure: I'm deeply invested in this work as a consultant for CBE.

[UPDATE: This post originally did not include the copy of the report design.  I'm copying Richard Day's approach to showing how the document shares the data.]

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Which teams will compete in the race for federal testing funds?

The federal government has launched a $350 million competition to develop higher quality student assessments.  Today. EdWeek describes three groups of states that are expected to apply:
Leaders of the groups told Education Week that Achieve, a Washington-based organization that works with states to craft standards and accountability systems, is talking with about 30 states, led by Florida, Massachusetts, and Louisiana, about devising a system of summative assessments that would include performance tasks.

The so-called MOSAIC consortium of states, which is focusing on formative assessments, is now working with what’s being called the SMARTER group, which focuses on computer-adaptive testing, and the “balanced assessment” consortium, which emphasizes curriculum-embedded, performance-based tests scored by teachers. That larger, merged group is led by Stanford University professor Linda Darling-Hammond and leaders of states such as Maine, West Virginia, and Oregon. The group currently includes about 40 states, according to Ms. Darling-Hammond. Consortia memberships overlap and are in flux.

Another consortium, including about eight states and headed by the National Center on Education and the Economy, aims to design high school tests modeled on the British “board exams.
Under Senate Bill 1, Kentucky could benefit from all three approaches: we need a summative test for accountability, formative tools to raise achievement, and end-of-course assessments to focus high school students tightly on key subjects.

Kentucky's STEM challenge: the bachelor's degree edition

Here's an issue worth all our attention.  As a state, we're increasing the total number of bachelors' degrees we award, and that growth is basically at the same pace as the national growth--but we're not going as well in the hard sciences that make the biggest economic difference.

The graph is built from these numbers, which in turn come from the 2001 and 2009 editions of the Digest of Education Statistics:

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

The common core sees content as central to reading success

In the Washington Post, E.D. Hirsch explains the big strength he sees in the most recent draft of the common core literacy standards:
Note the unusual title it carries: “Common Core Standards for English Language Arts and Literacy in History/Social Studies & Science.” The title shouts that language mastery requires knowledge of history, and science, (music and fine arts I hope will be included in due course) not just fiction and poetry. It states explicitly that these non-literary subjects should be generously represented in the long classroom hours devoted to literacy.

This emphasis on non-literary content is defended on the grounds that building “a foundation of knowledge in these fields will give [students] the background to be better readers in all content areas.”

That is an especially important consideration for the early grades, which now spend up to half the school day on literacy. Here is something new under the sun. It resists the infamous narrowing of the curriculum. And it is an important reform also for helping to overcome the test-score gap, which is essentially a knowledge gap, between racial and ethnic groups.
Last year, I worked on describing the same link this way:
Finally, this idea is why I'm obsessed with serious content from the earliest days of school. I want it taught anyway that works, from seeing plants grow to building models of the solar system, from acting out the Mayflower to sharing songs about Abraham Lincoln. That work helps students begin building a mental web of reading-and-science, and reading-and-history, and reading-and-economics. The stronger that web is early, the more prepared they will be to use books later in school to get more knowledge, with depth and detail, connected to the topics they understand early on.

Two more Races to the Top start now: the assessment competition

There's been lots of discussion about the federal Race to the Top, almost always about the $4 billion competition for big shifts in state policy around standards, data, teachers and leaders, and intervention in weak schools. 

Separately,* $350 million from RTTT will be awarded in two additional competitions, and that race  launched today.

The Comprehensive Assessment process will choose a maximum of two state consortia to develop assessments of whether students are on track for college readiness, and must include mathematics and English language arts in grades 3-8 and at least once in high school.   Maximum awards for each group will be $160 million to be spent over four years.

The High School Course Assessment process will award one state consortium up to $30 million to "measure student knowledge and skills against a common set of expectations that are rigorous and designed to ensure that students who pass the course assessment are on track to being college- and career-ready."

Without trying to blog the full details now, I'll mention three things that jump out.

First, each consortium must include at least fifteen states.  Clearly, this process is a serious push to create greater unity in education goals than the U.S. has had in the past.  Kentucky has been actively involved in all the discussions about how to share this work, so we're ready to compete on that issue.

Second, each application has a "competitive priority" for approaches with public higher education backing.  That is, the proposal can get extra credit points if the member states' institutions commit to help develop the assessment and to use the results to exempt students from remedial classes.  Equally clearly, this is a push both to have the assessments  align with college expectations and to have students perceive the test as important to their own college ambitions.  With our strong collaboration on SB 1, Kentucky's ready for that.

Third, the applications want the full testing up and running in 2014-15, with part of the high school course testing due in a year earlier.  Here in the Bluegrass, where we've got a statutory commitment to a new assessment system by 2012, we're past ready: the feds are willing to wait a lot longer than we are for the transition to a new testing approach.

The application documents are here, and I'll blog more when I've had time for a deeper read.

* Really.  It's separate money.  In the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act/ARRA/stimulus bill, the total RTTT entry is $4.35 billion, and very early on, Secretary Duncan set aside the $350 million part for new assessments, while the main $4 billion went for the things we've been discussing for the last seven months.

Monday, April 5, 2010

No apologies for our RTTT unity points (not even to the New York Times)

The Times reported yesterday that:
Officials from several states criticized the scoring of the [Race to the Top] contest, which favored states able to gain support from 100 percent of school districts and local teachers’ unions for Obama administration objectives like expanding charter schools, reworking teacher evaluation systems and turning around low-performing schools.
The article goes so far as to quote Colorado's governor as saying the outcome was like an "American skater with a Soviet judge from the 1980s.”

Ahem.

Right in the application, the scoring guide made it perfectly clear that 45 out of 500 points would be awarded based on local commitment to implementing the plan.

Those points were just as well publicized as the 32 points for charters, the 138 points for great teachers and leaders, and everything else that counted in judging the applications.

Here in Kentucky, we downloaded the application and read it.

The ones who get it done

Jay Matthews of the Washington Post writes of the passing of a mighty educator:
The stunning success at Garfield led U.S. presidents to endorse Escalante's view that impoverished children can achieve as much as affluent kids if they are given enough extra study time and encouragement to learn.

In 1987, 26 percent of all Mexican American students in the country who passed the AP Calculus exams attended a single high school: Garfield. That meant that hundreds of thousands of overlooked students could probably do as well if they got what Escalante was giving out. But what was that?

Whenever I suggested that the great teaching I was seeing at Garfield might be the reason so many students were succeeding in AP, people at parties dismissed me as romantic and naive. 
Well, yes, it's common wisdom that poor kids can't succeed, except that devoted educators rebut that wisdom, over and over, by finding a way to beat those poverty odds.  Thank you, Mr. Escalante, for being one of that glorious breed!

Classroom assessment for learning: moving toward a deeper understanding


Classroom Assessment for Student Learning: Doing It Right - Using It Well is my new big reading project.

It's a big-but-accessible professional development book, authored by Rick Stiggins, Judith Arter, Jan Chappuis, and Steve Chappuis. 

Here's the central point, taken from the opening paragraph:
Used with skill, assessment can motivate the unmotivated, restore the desire to learn, and encourage students to keep learning, and it can actually create -not simply measure- increased achievement.
Yet again, there's that "sunlit vision" for students that drew me into Stiggins' Assessment Manifesto last year, and led me to develop posts like this one.

Around the state, this book is in very wide use.  I'll be blogging about its contents in part because it's valuable background on what's happening in our schools, and in part because any idea that offers us classrooms where students do both stronger work and happier work is exciting news.

Friday, April 2, 2010

Doing the ten books thing

There's a current blogging fad of listing ten books that had a mighty influence on your life,  and as my Friday-afternoon wind down, I'll join in.


Feminism: the Essential Historical Writings, edited by Miriam Schneir, was my real introduction to American civics, grafting debates on inclusion and responsibility right into my bones, especially Elizabeth Cady Stanton's speeches and Sarah Grimke's letters.

Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes were Watching God  was out of print when my mother' sister pushed it into my sixteen-year-old hands.  That great work on girl-becoming-woman and character-outweighing-conditions and passion-making-the-world-worth-having has gained its proper public recognition in the years since, including a place in the common core exemplars of the kind of reading students should take on in school.

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn taught me most of the physics I know and put paradigms and paradigm shifts at the heart of my understanding of big ideas.  As the common core effort and the state of Kentucky move on to developing science standards, the issue of paradigms will be showing up in my blogging analysis.

On the Condition of the Working Classes was the first in a line of Catholic social encyclicals that (as a set) became my framework for thinking about economies and economic participation, with my first question always being about how many people are able to build up the world around them.  Education systems create the personal capacities and the structural supports for  large numbers to do that building for themselves, and that's why education is where I do my own work.


E.D. Hirsch's Cultural Literacy is regular blog fodder already, grounding both my understanding of reading and my energetic commitment to substantive standards in history, science, literature, and art.

Sources of the Self is Charles Taylor's great analysis of the origins of modern understandings of individuality.  I know better than to attempt a summary of his deep argument, but I'll mention that his concept of the "affirmation of everyday life" as a Reformation breakthrough shows up here every time I tuck a family detail into my writing.

Albion's Seed is one book every participant in Kentucky public affairs needs to read. David Hacket Fischer traces early immigration from the British isles to North America, pointing out how regional differences across the Atlantic became central to regional cultures here.  If you once think of Virginia plantations as Wessex and of Appalachian settlers as "Borderers," you never stop. If you add in that Daniel Boone's family had Midlands-to-Midatlantic roots but Abraham Lincoln radiated East-Anglia-to-New-England approaches, you've got a new lens for nearly everything that happens in the Bluegrass State.

Abraham Kuyper's Lectures on Calvinism crossed my path a decade ago. Kuyper, both a Dutch Reformed minister and a Dutch Prime Minister, offers a bridge between those encyclicals mentioned earlier and my Presbyterianism.  His distinction between the political (dis)engagement of church institutions and the political engagement of Christians as citizens is especially helpful.

Between Two Worlds: The Inner Lives of Children of Divorce rests on careful interviews backed up by systematic surveys, undergirded by author Elizabeth Marquardt's own generous and nurturing spirit.  I grew up knowing that for many in my mother's generation, a hundred inarticulate concerns suddenly clicked into clarity when Freidan published The Feminine Mystique. For a subset of adults my age and younger, Marquardt's work provides click after click after click of understanding about our own past and continuing experience.  It's not a recognized classic yet, but it should be and will be.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Adequacy and equity (India steps up)

The Associated Press, via EdWeek, reports:
A law making primary education compulsory in India came into effect Thursday, opening the door for millions of impoverished children who have never made it to school because their parents could not afford the fees or because they were forced to work instead.

The new law entitles all children between the ages of 6 and 14 to a free education, regardless of their social status, gender or income level. Some 8 million children—mostly girls—are currently out of school, according to the U.N. children's agency. The law is expected to also help educate Dalit children, who as members of India's lowest caste are treated as outcasts and are often barred from class.

"Today, our government comes before you to redeem the pledge of giving all our children the right to elementary education," India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said in a televised national address. "This demonstrates our national commitment to the education of our children and to the future of India."
A moment for hearty congratulations to India, and hearty gratitude that the basics of free education for all children have been settled here for generations.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Kentucky continues funding higher education above national average.

For fiscal year 2009, Kentucky public higher education's funding per full-time equivalent pupil was (again) above national average. 

The amount paid by state appropriations was above average. 

The amount paid by students and their families, known as "net tuition" after financial aid, was above average. 

And the total was above average. 

Thus:
These numbers come from the annual State Higher Education Finance 2009 report  issues by the State Higher Education Executive Officers group.

More exactly, the numbers graphed above are unadjusted figures from the SHEF 2009 work.  In the main report, the figures show Kentucky figures adjusted upward because of our lower cost of living and our enrollment mix.  There, Kentucky's net tuition paid by families is shown as $5,215, the appropriation figure as $7,969, and the total revenue as $13,184.  I backed out that adjustment by multiplying the Kentucky figures by the 0.895 adjustment factor shown in the report's "Technical Paper Table 2."   Graphing the adjusted numbers would make Kentucky's spending appear still further ahead of national average.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Points gained and lost on Kentucky's RTTT application

Kentucky scored 418.8 points on our round one Race to the Top application, and missed 81.2. Here's a summary of where we succeeded and fell short.


The absence of charter schools shows up at the bottom, being the source of 32 of the points we missed in the general category.

And now, on to trying to designing ways to claim more of the points in each area where we fell short.

RTTT: Kentucky ninth among Round 1 applicants, aiming to score higher in Round 2

In announcing Race to the Top Awards to Delaware and Tennessee, the federal education department also released state scores on the 0 to 500 scale.  Here are the top 10 final scores:

  1. Delaware 454.6
  2. Tennessee 444.2
  3. Georgia 433.6
  4. Florida 431.4
  5. Illinois 423.8
  6. South Carolina 423.2
  7. Pennsylvania 420.0
  8. Rhode Island 419.0
  9. Kentucky 418.8
  10. Ohio 418.6
The full list can be downloaded here (choose the "summary chart" above the list of states).

The Department also anticipates 10 to 15 grants in the second round.  Being ninth among all states in the first competition means starting out at seventh among all those going on to further competition.

Since all states will try to improve their scores, Kentucky will certainly need to study all the scoring and work to make our application stronger for the next round.  But it certainly looks as though time spent on those upgrades could bring us mighty benefits in the rest of the competition.

Kentucky on the move (with or without RTTT)

Only Delaware and Tennessee received first-round Race to the Top grants.  Kentucky, though a finalist, did not receive funding for our plans.

And yet...

Stronger standards will go forward, with Kentucky leaders committed to the common core approach and a summit to start equipping teachers to use those standards just two weeks away.

More effective evaluation methods will go forward, with new designs already under discussion and pilot districts being sought.

Better-aligned principal and teacher preparation programs will go forward, with the Education Professional Standards board already in the process of checking university programs for principals and masters degrees against higher standards and already at work on higher standards for the core teacher program as well.

More intense intervention in the state's weakest schools will go forward, with a new regulation already in place and new, more demanding audits already underway.

And better ntegrated P-16 data systems will go forward, though I don't have evidence on hand about  how quickly we'll see valuable insights coming from analysis of that combined information.

We do, indeed, have a state-wide agenda for moving our children higher, and not winning the first round of RTTT won't stop us from doing the work.

That very fact, that shared agenda and that determination to push it forward, will be our biggest asset in applying for RTTT's second round.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Our NAEP city districts: who was in the 2009 sample?

Reading blog post on how "our reading growth skipped our city districts," a commenter asked "So, what type of district is JCPS classified as? How about FCPS?"

NAEP samples each state, and usually we don't know which districts were chosen for the sample. For 2009, we know that Jefferson County was included, and I think we can be confident that its students were counted as city residents. We don't know, though, what other city districts were included (Fayette? Bowling Green? Covington?) or what districts were sampled as suburban, town, or rural locations.

How do we know about the Jefferson County part?  The  Courier-Journal reported that:
In Kentucky, 7,489 fourth- and eighth-graders from 316 schools were randomly selected to take the test.

Of that number, approximately 2,800 students in both grade levels from Jefferson County Public Schools were tested, said Bob Rodosky, director of testing and accountability for the district.

“I am really encouraged by the state’s results. and I would like to believe that Jefferson County had something to do with the rise of those scores,” he said.

NAEP typically doesn’t break down test scores by district.

However, Jefferson County is one of several urban school districts that participates in the Trial Urban District Assessment — those district’s test scores will be released in May.

Our reading growth skipped our city districts (not good)

The improved reading skills shown in 2009 NAEP results occurred mainly in our rural, town, and suburban districts.  Among city residents, scale scores:
  • went up a single point for fourth-graders who qualify for free-and-reduced-price lunches
  • went down a single point for fourth-graders who do not qualify for the lunch program
  • were flat for eight-graders from both economic situations

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Reading growth even for most groups, slower for black students in grade 4

Here's a full array of disaggregated results from the fourth grade NAEP reading results released yesterday.   Most gaps stayed the same, but the race gap widened while the lunch gap narrowed slightly.


These graphs are a good illustration of a key feature of statistical significance: a change that is significant with a large sample of students may not be counted as significant for a smaller group.  For example, the four-point improvement for students without disabilities is significant, but the four-point improvement for students with disabilities is not--because fewer students with disabilities were tested.

The three-point movement for students in the free-and-reduced-lunch program is also significant, while the three-point changes for male, female, and white students are [not].  The two points for students not in the lunch program are not significant growth.  Unsurprisingly, raising black student results one point is not significant either.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Wow! Kentucky reading scores above national average, rising faster than nearly all states

Wow!

2009 NAEP reading scores are out, showing Kentucky students reading above national average, by a statistically significant margin, in both fourth and eighth grade.  

There's more.  From 2007 to 2009, only three states showed significant fourth grade improvement, and only nine states showed significant eight grade improvement. One state, one and only one, improved at both levels: Kentucky!

And more.  The Prichard Committee has urged Kentucky to move its educational system into the top 20 in the country by 2020.  In reading, we've arrived.  In fourth grade, we're tied for ninth, and in eighth grade, we're tied for sixteenth.

For all the educators, parents, students, and leaders who made this happen for Kentucky, this warrants a one minute pause to celebrate--followed (of course) by getting back to work on moving achievement even higher.

Wow!

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Senate budget adds $55 million in P-12 cuts to the House's $56 million in reductions

An earlier post today pointed out that the Senate plan requires districts to provide two more days of instruction than the House budget--but does not provide any funding for those days.  Now, let's turn to the full set of P-12 spending plans.

The House 2012 budget offered $56 million less for P-12 education than the state's original budget for the current (2010) fiscal year.

The Senate version cuts an additional $55 million from the House approach.

The Senate plan has just one line item with a larger 2021 budget than the House plan, providing:
  • $25.5 million more for local educators’ health insurance
The Senate plan pulls back from all the other House increases, with reductions of:
  • $34 million from school facilities
  • $2 million from unidentified spending that likely includes the  state's education technology network and the operations of the state department 
  • $300 thousand from local vocational schools
  • $284 thousand from school safety
The Senate plan also cuts many other areas where the House had already cut, including taking:
  • $24 million more from SEEK base funding
  • $1.2 million more from Tier I
  • $6.5 million more from teachers retirement
  • $5 million more from intervention in weak schools using highly skilled educations and school improvement grants
  • $2 million more from preschool
  • $1.4 million more from family resource and youth service centers
  • $473 thousand more from the Read to Achieve program
  • $438 thousand more from school technology
  • $427 thousand more from state vocational schools
  • $356 thousand from the schools for the blind and deaf
  • $321 thousand more from extended school services
  • $26t thousand more from State Agency Children
  • $235 thousand more from state testing
  • $194 thousand more from the Education Professional Standards Board
  • $172 thousand more from gifted and talented
  • $151 thousand more from professional development
  • $121 thousand more from debt service on money borrowed for school technology
  • $16 thousand more from textbooks
  • $479 thousand more from other local grants
  • $356 thousand more from other state grants
The next step in the budget process will be a House vote on the Senate changes. It's essentially certain that the House reject the Senate changes, leading to a conference committee where Senators and Representatives try to negotiate a budget both houses can support. 

Senate budget requires two instructional days but does not fund them

The Senate sent its amended version of the 2010-2012 state budget back to the House yesterday, amid  reports that the Senate version keeps the two added instructional days that the House had cut.

Actually, the Senate budget requires districts to provide those instructional days, but it does not fund them.

State funding comes through the SEEK formula as “Base” and “Tier I” funding. Here’s how the Senate numbers are lower than the House ones:

The Senate version of the budget adds money to one P-12 line item: educators’ health insurance receive $31.3 million more in FY 2011 than the House budget does, and $25.5 million more in FY 2012.

The Senate version cuts every single other P-12 line item. Beyond the reductions to SEEK above, the Senate provides $14 million less for FY 2011 and $55.7 million less for FY 2012 in those other programs.

The Senate version also gives districts special permission to cut costs in ways that are not usually allowed by law, including:
  • Hiring preschool teachers do not meet current certification requirements.
  • Eliminating kindergarten aides.
  • Raising class sizes above the current legal limits
  • Using money set aside for capital improvements (for example, buildings and renovations) for current expenses instead.
In effect, the Senate budget proposes to force districts to fund the two instructional days while providing significantly less funding to cover education costs than the House version (and the House budget already provided lower funding than past state budgets). 

I'll share more on the other cuts later in the day....

Monday, March 22, 2010

Updating our giant steps: SB 1, common core, and RTTT

Can the three biggest things happening in Kentucky education fit on one page?  We shared one version in January, and now it seems like a time for an updated edition.  You can download the PDF version here, or read on.

THREE GIANT STEPS
FOR KENTUCKY EDUCATION

MARCH 2010 OVERVIEW OF KEY DEVELOPMENTS
FROM THE PRICHARD COMMITTEE FOR ACADEMIC EXCELLENCE

SENATE BILL 1

Senate Bill 1, passed in 2009, requires Kentucky to upgrade its standards for what students will learn. Our new law says the standards must be shorter, clearer, and better focused on students being ready for college, work, and global competition. To match the new standards, Kentucky will use new tests starting in the spring of 2012. Current teachers will receive specialized training on how to teach the new standards well, and teacher preparation programs will equip future teachers with the same skills.

COMMON CORE STANDARDS SHARED BY MANY STATES

Kentucky is not developing its new standards alone. Instead, we are working with many other states to develop “common core” standards in language arts and mathematics. Nationally respected experts are leading the effort, using learning research and information on how each subject is taught in the countries with the world’s highest academic results. All the participating states have contributed to revisions, and public comments are now being gathered. A final draft for those subjects will be available later this spring.

On February 10, Kentucky state-level leaders responsible for K-12 education, higher education, and teacher preparation held a joint meeting and formally agreed that the language arts and mathematics standards are the right direction for our students. Because of our Senate Bill 1, we expect to be ahead of most states in preparing current and future teachers to use the standards effectively. In the future, Kentucky and other states will be able to collaborate on developing tests, textbooks, technology, and professional development to help teachers use the new standards effectively.

THE FEDERAL RACE TO THE TOP COMPETITION

Kentucky is one of sixteen finalists in the competition for Race to the Top grants from the United States Department of Education. The winning states will share $4 billion in funding to implement plans to make their school systems among the best in the world, including proposed steps on:

• Standards, including classroom implementation and good tests to check student progress.
• Data systems to help teachers identify student needs and effective learning strategies.
• Evaluation and support systems to strengthen teachers and school leaders.
• Major changes to schools that repeatedly fail to deliver acceptable student performance.

Since Kentucky is already committed to Senate Bill 1 and the common core standards, the Race to the Top competition is an opportunity to get the funding we need to implement those changes quickly and well. Kentucky has asked for $200 million to use over five years, with half of the funding going to school districts for local work and half being used at the state level to implement changes that will support excellence in all schools. The winners of the first Race to the Top grants will be announced in the spring of 2010, with additional grants made later in the year.

Sunday, March 21, 2010

Understanding Kentucky's educational history by region

Following up on the earlier income map, here's a look Kentucky adult high school attainment.  It uses the Census Bureau's thirty "microdata" areas as the results are mapped in  a great MACED report,  The lowest attainment levels cluster heavily in Appalachian Kentucky and in urban Jefferson County, while the highest median incomes are found in northern and eastern portions of Jefferson County and both portions of Fayette County.

And here's the map for adults holding associates degrees and higher educational credentials.  Here, high attainment again clusters in our largest cities, but lower attainment is clusters in several different part of our state.

Common standards and the mathematics for each grade (key information for parents)

For parents, the most helpful element of the draft common core mathematics standards may be the opening paragraph for each grade.  For example, the section for kindergarten begins this way:
In Kindergarten, instructional time should focus on two critical areas: (1) representing, comparing and ordering whole numbers and joining and separating sets; (2) describing shapes and space. More learning time in Kindergarten should be devoted to number than to other topics.
Two to four critical areas for each elementary and middle school are listed in similar paragraphs that list these elements:

Grade 1
• Developing understanding of addition, subtraction, and strategies for additions and subtractions within 20
• Developing understanding of whole number relationships, including grouping in tens and ones,
• Developing understanding of linear measurement and measuring lengths
• Composing and decomposing geometric shapes

Grade 2
• Developing understanding of base-ten notation
• Developing fluency with additions and subtractions within 20 and fluency with multi-digit addition and subtraction
• Describing and analyzing shapes

Grade 3
• Developing understanding of multiplication and division and strategies for multiplication and division within 100
• Developing understanding of fractions, starting with unit fractions
• Developing understanding of the structure of rectangular arrays and of area
• Describing and analyzing two-dimensional shapes

Grade 4
• Continuing to develop understanding and fluency with whole number multiplication, and developing understanding of multi-digit whole number division
• Developing an understanding of addition and subtraction of fractions with like denominators, multiplication of fractions by whole numbers, and division of whole numbers with fractional answers
• Developing an understanding of area
• Understanding that geometric figures can be analyzed and classified using properties such as having parallel sides, perpendicular sides, particular angle measures, and symmetry.

Grade 5
• Developing fluency with addition and subtraction of fractions, developing understanding of the multiplication of fractions and of division of fractions in limited cases (fractions divided by whole numbers and whole numbers divided by unit fractions)
• Developing understanding of and fluency with division of multi-digit whole numbers
• Developing understanding of and fluency with addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of decimals
• Developing understanding of volume

Grade 6
• Connecting ratio and rate to whole number multiplication and division
• Developing understanding of and fluency with division of fractions and developing fluency with multiplication of fractions
• Developing understanding of and using formulas to determine areas of two-dimensional shapes and distinguishing between volume and surface area of three-dimensional shapes
• Writing, interpreting, and using expressions and equations

Grade 7
• Developing understanding of and applying proportional relationships
• Developing understanding of operations with rational numbers and solving linear equations
• Analyzing two- and three-dimensional space and figures using distance, angle, similarity, and congruence
• Drawing inferences about populations based on samples

Grade 8
• Solving linear equations and systems of linear equations
• Grasping the concept of a function and using functions to describe quantitative relationships
• Understanding and applying the Pythagorean Theorem

Those paragraphs are followed by a slightly longer explanation each item, and then by the full standards for the grade.  All three levels of detail are helpful, but I predict that the outline above (with any modifications made in the final edition) will be the version parents find most helpful in understanding their children's studies and in providing home support for students to succeed.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

Understanding Kentucky income by region

When the Census Bureau divides Kentucky into thirty "microdata" areas and MACED maps the results, there's a clear pattern to Kentucky incomes.  The lowest median household incomes are found in rural southeastern Kentucky and in urban Jefferson County, while the highest median incomes are found in northern and eastern portions of Jefferson County and a (noncentral) portion of Fayette County.

Replacing NCLB (part 4): staying serious about achievement gaps

The Obama administration has published a "blueprint" for revising the Elementary and Secondary Education Act and replacing NCLB.  My earlier posts addressed its approaches to standards, assessment, and schoolwide accountability. Now it's time to look at the rules for student subgroups.

The "challenge school" interventions for the lowest results will apply both to schools with overall weak growth and to schools that move too slowly on achievement gaps.  Thus:
Schools that are not closing significant, persistent achievement gaps will constitute another category of Challenge schools. In these schools, districts will be required to implement data-driven interventions to support those students who are farthest behind and close the achievement gap.
Added requirements for school data systems will also make gap issues easier to track:
To foster public accountability for results and help focus improvement and support efforts, states must have data systems in place to gather information that is critical to determining how schools and districts are progressing in preparing students to graduate from high school college- and career-ready. States and districts will collect and make public data relating to student academic achievement and growth in English language arts and mathematics, student academic achievement in science, and if states choose, student academic achievement and growth in other subjects, such as history. At the high school level, this data will also include graduation rates, college enrollment rates, and rates of college enrollment without need for remediation. All of these data must be disaggregated by race, gender, ethnicity, disability status, English Learner status, and family income.

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

In RTTT finals, Kentucky stands alone without charter legislation

Today Kentucky sent a distinguished delegation to Washington to present our Race to the Top application, and we're now just a few weeks from the first round of awards.

While charter school rules provide only a fraction of the points that count toward winning, Kentucky is likely behind the other states on that part of the competition.  An e-mail question today led me to go check on charters in the other fifteen states who have gotten this far.  The answer I found was that all the other finalists have charter schools, though the numbers reported (here) vary pretty dramatically:
  • 416 charter schools in Florida
  • 328 in Ohio
  • 157 in Colorado
  • 144 in New York
  • 135 in Pennsylvania
  • 96 in North Carolina
  • 85 in Georgia
  • 77 in Louisiana
  • 62 in Massachusetts
  • 57 in the District of Columbia
  • 39 in Illinois
  • 39 in South Carolina
  • 22 in Tennessee
  • 18 in Delaware
  • 13 in Rhode Island

For shared prosperity, build education and job opportunities for working poor families

The Mountain Association for Community Economic Development recommends systematic attention to families that, even with hard work, are not earning enough to make their families self-sufficient.

Arguing that opportunity for those families is "a path to shared prosperity in the commonwealth,"  MACED provides an overview of their current challenges and policy proposals for education, job creation, and other supports.

Here are the education recommendations:
• Kentucky should overhaul its financial aid programs to prioritize need-based programs like CAP with increased funding, and should restructure financial aid to make it more accessible to adult students, including those attending part-time.
• Kentucky should expand its Career Pathways strategy with dedicated dollars in order to better link education and training to long-term job opportunities with career ladders based on key sectors in particular regions.
• Related to Career Pathways, Kentucky should offer more flexible delivery of edu cation so that working families can more easily access the training and credentials they need.
• Kentucky should move adult education funding to national average levels in order to close the gap in basic literacy and educational attainment and help students reach the first rung of the ladder to good jobs and stronger economic contributions.
• The state and the Council on Postsecondary Education should work to avoid unreasonable tuition increases that put an unfair burden of the cost of higher education on students and families that increasingly cannot afford it.
Two further notes:  First, I had the pleasure of working with MACED on early drafts of this report.  Second, it has wonderful maps showing how Kentucky challenges spread out across regions of the state, and I'm planning to blog several of them in the coming days.

Building teaching quality at the pre-school level

The Pew Center on the States rounds up research showing that preschool teachers' educational background matters:
Research indicates that higher levels of education and training can help improve teachers’ interactions with children in ways that positively affect learning. Studies suggest that skilled professionals can more effectively promote and support young children’s cognitive, social and emotional growth when they know how to capitalize on the period of critical early brain development before age five. Pre-k teachers who have earned bachelor’s degrees and have additional, specialized training in early childhood education have generally been found to be more effective than those without these qualifications. In addition to improving the quality of teaching, stronger preparation requirements may help to professionalize the early childhood workforce. The resulting higher pay, in turn, would attract a better-quality workforce, reduce turnover and provide greater incentives toward the ongoing improvement of practice.
Angela Brant at the Prichard Committee points out that Kentucky is on the right track on this issue, e-mailing me that "New teachers hired to teach in the state funded preschool programs must have a bachelor’s degree with an Interdisciplinary early childhood education certificate."

Sunday, March 14, 2010

Replacing NCLB (Part 1): aiming for college and career readiness

"College and career readiness by 2020" may soon replace proficiency by 2014" as the main goal of the  federal P-12 education programs.

Friday, the U.S. Department of Education announced its "blueprint" for revising the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, the big section of federal law that includes the Title 1 program for students from low-income families, along with other sections on issues like school innovation, safe and drug free schools, children from migrant families, and many other education concerns.

The first big change is the push toward college and career readiness. Under the administration proposal, states will have will two options for reading and mathematics standards:
  • First, they can “upgrade their existing standards, working with their 4-year public university system to certify that mastery of the standards ensures that a student will not need to take remedial coursework upon admission to a postsecondary institution in the system.”
  • Second, they can adopt standards in common with other states.
Kentucky has, of course, already chosen the second option, and many states are likely to follow that approach.  However, states that prefer to continue using unique standards different from all other jurisdictions will be able to do so and able to continue receiving federal funding--provided their K-12 and postsecondary systems can agree that their home-grown standards are high enough to make remediation unnecessary.

States will also be required to set standards for science and for success in learning English.

As always, the approach the administration lists in its blueprint is sure to undergo major revisions during congressional hearings, votes, and negotiations.  This is only the start of the multi-branch discussion of how to change federal policy and funding.

Replacing NCLB (part 2): what's coming on assessments?

The proposed blueprint for revising the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (and replacing No Child Left Behind) calls for each state to use "high quality" assessments aligned with its college-and-career-ready standards.

The blueprint expects those assessments to allow reporting on students' growth from year to year, and it proposes federal grants to support improvements in assessment methods.

Beyond that, though, it's hard to find details on what "high quality" will mean.

I have a hunch about about why those specifics are not filled in.  I think the department wants the goals for ESEA assessment to be closely related to the ones they will use for the upcoming $350 million competition to develop new assessments using money from the federal stimulus bill.   The draft specifications for that competition will be published sometime in the next few months, comments will be gathered, and then a final set of application requirements will be set.  I predict that when that application is released, the assessment goals listed there will also become the assessment specifics of the executive branch proposal for ESEA.

Two added details: The blueprint is the administration's opening bid, and it's essentially certain that what becomes final law will include important changes from the starting proposal.  Second, for those following the money, the $350 million for assessments is actually a slice of the Race to the Top program.  The total appropriation was $4.35 billion, with $4 billion already scheduled be handed out in the two rounds of the main competition that has received plenty of public attention.  As Secretary Duncan announced last fall, the rest of that pot will be distributed in a separate competition to develop new and stronger state assessments.

Replacing NCLB (part 3): accountability in three slices

Accountability will be tougher on a few schools and easier under most if the U.S. Department of Education's approach to revising the Elementary and Secondary Education Act becomes law.

For the five percent of schools with the weakest growth,  states will be required to use one of four aggressive interventions:
  • closure
  • restart under outside management
  • turnaround by replacing the principal and half the staff
  • transformation that includes a new principal, strengthened staffing, a new instructional program, and other steps
That list may sound familiar.  In the RTTT competition, states could earn points by including those options in their applications.  In the separate school improvement grant section of the stimulus bill, a state's persistently low performing schools can receive added funding if they implement an approach from that same list--and the Courier-Journal reported on those options just yesterday.

For the "next weakest" five percent, there will be a watch list and some lesser required actions.

At the opposite end of the spectrum, schools with the strongest student growth will receive some type of recognition and reward.  The recognition could play a valuable role in spotlighting schools that "beat the poverty odds" and building public confidence that high goals really are in reach even for students who have often been allowed to underperform. 

For most schools—the ones delivering growth in the middle range—the proposal will allow “local flexibility to determine the appropriate improvement and support strategies.” That part sounds dramatically less prescriptive than the current law.  Under NCLB, schools can move rapidly into deeper and deeper tiers of sanctions, and it has been quite possible that nearly all schools could end up under state intervention.

So, if only the bottom 10 percent of schools will be subject to state intervention, does the "blueprint" represent a big step away from accountability for the rest?  I think not, for two reasons.

First, states will be reporting school success in keeping students on track to college-and-career-readiness, and that's a goal that's easier for parents and other citizens to understand and support.  That new clarity can increase old-fashioned pressure--the kind that comes through citizens calling elected officials and candidates explaining themselves to voters--to improve educational outcomes.  A strong spotlight on schools that are moving the fastest can also promote healthy popular expectations that others will also improve what they're doing.

Second, every state department of education has to choose its battles, and it can only keep strong pressure on a small group of schools at a time.  Otherwise, it ends up with too many elected officials pushing back on behalf of constituents.  As a result, I think the administration proposal may be setting a target that's at the high end of what's truly feasible.   My hope is for a system that presses as hard as realistically possible, but that doesn't promise more than can honestly be delivered.  The planned pressure on a short list of schools that are clearly achieving far too little strikes me as a credible approach for what truly can be done.


Let me quickly underline the word "proposal."  By the time Congress passes and the President signs new ESEA legislation, many elements will be different from this first set of administration recommendations.

Of disabilities and diplomas

On the one hand, the Enquirer has a great article on college options for students with disabilities.  Do read it, and do appreciate the report on a local district's efforts to build awareness of opportunities for those students to earn their degrees.

On the other hand, the article has a terrible, terrible mismatch of Ohio and Kentucky numbers:
In Ohio, where seniors with disabilities can qualify for diplomas if they complete individualized education plans, more than 15,000 seniors with disabilities made up 14 percent of the Class of 2008's 105,700 graduates.

Kentucky's 40,099 graduates in 2008 included 187 students who graduated after individualized education plans, said Lisa Gross, Kentucky's education department spokeswoman. Another 453 students received "certificates of completion" instead of diplomas because severe disabilities prevented them from completing the classes to qualify for a diploma, she said.
That Ohio "more than 15,000" is plausible as the number of students who finish high school and could go on to college with disabilities.

In Kentucky, 187 is the 2008 number of students with disabilities who graduated after more than four years in high school based on an IEP that called for them to spend that added time in school.   The source is Kentucky District Data Profiles: School Year 2007-2008.

Many, many more students with disabilities graduated in the regular four year span.  As a rough estimate, I'd offer the fact that 3,830 students with disabilities finished senior year writing portfolios.   Some of them may not have graduated, but most who finished that work in April surely collected diplomas in May or early June.

Of course, we should still be worried even by that number, because that class lost an amazing number of students with disabilities over its years in school. Taking numbers tested each spring, here's how the count slid downward:

Those losses are disturbing. Some may come from students whose identification legitimately changed.  Many, though, must reflect students who gave up before finishing school, and at least a few probably reflect students who still needed special services but who stopped receiving them.

We should be graduating many more students with disabilities from high school, sending many more to higher education, and cheering many more on as they complete their postsecondary studies.