Saturday, March 13, 2010

A note from the Boss

Well now everything dies baby that's a fact
But maybe everything that dies someday comes back
Put your makeup on fix your hair up pretty
And meet me tonight in Atlantic City
SB 1 received its final votes a year ago today.  A year on, I like the way the gamble is turning out.

(Lyrics and audio available here  and previous blog post here)

Friday, March 12, 2010

Intensive new audits starting early (with help from the federal stimulus)

The Courier-Journal is reporting on the first steps of Kentucky's new approach to schools with a multi-year history of weak performance:
Shawnee principal Keith Look said the process was “very intense.”

“They are looking at everything you do at the school through a leadership lens,” Look said.

Look, who is in his second year as principal at Shawnee, said the 11-member team of retired educators spent two days collecting test and other data before spending the rest of the week interviewing every staff member in the school.

“They also observed each teacher twice, talked to about 40-50 students and interviewed parents and community members,” he said. “They also talked to SBDM members.”
This is an early start on the audit and intervention process the legislature approved at the very start of the current session.  During the voting on the bill, the Commissioner did not expect the new rules to apply until 2010 test scores came in.

What's changed? According to the article, "the districts are being audited this year because they wanted to be eligible to receive up to $1.5 million in federal School Improvement Grants this year."  Those grants are yet another part of the federal stimulus legislation, also known as the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.

That is, while state law would have allowed districts to put off the audits until next fall, the ARRA offered an incentive to start right away, and at least one eligible district has chosen to take up the offer.

$59 million in cuts to state support for current P-12 students

During this terrible recession, what kind of damage is being done to state funding for P-12 education?

Comparing the original budget for this fiscal year to the budget the House just approved for the 2012 fiscal year shows a reduction of roughly $59 million in planned state spending for current educational services.  $103 million in reductions to specific programs is only partly offset by $44 million in increases to other efforts.

The $103 million in cuts includes:
  • $56 million from base SEEK funding
  • $21 million from textbooks
  • $9 million from teachers retirement premiums
  • $3 million from reading grants
  • $3 million from SEEK Tier I equalization funding
  • $2 million from school technology
  • $1.7 million from family resource and youth service centers
  • $1.5 million from preschool
  • $1.2 million from the Education Professional Standards Board
  • $512 thousand from the schools for the blind and the deaf
  • $412 thousand from intervention in weak schools using highly skilled educations and school improvement grants
  • $264 thousand from extended school services
  • $239 thousand from testing
  • $219 thousand from state agency children
  • $142 thousand from gifted and talented
  • $125 thousand from professional development
  • $316 thousand from other local programs
  • $1.3 million from other state level services
The $44 million in added funding includes:
  • $29 million for facilities (including school construction plans described by House leaders as a way to create jobs and strengthen the state economy)
  • $12 million for educators' health insurance
  • $300 thousand for local vocational schools
  • $76 thousand for school safety
  • $3.5 million in growth that is not itemized (probably mainly costs of the KEN network and possibly also some costs of operating the Department of Education)
There's also  one other item to mention.   The House budget has a second line item for teachers retirement, used for state payments to sustain benefits for teachers who have already retired and to pay back earlier borrowing from the retirement system.  The House plans a $44 million increase in that item.  That money will go to the important state purpose of meeting commitments to those who educated past students.  However, since those dollars do not help us educate current students, they are not part of my calculation of a net $59 million loss in what will go to meet current education needs.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Changes in the new draft standards (nearly all for the better)

For readers who looked at the January 13 draft of the grade-by-grade common core standards, the new edition does show important revisions.

Grades 6, 7, and 8 now have separate standards in both documents, definitely a plus for parents trying to benchmark what their children should be doing. In the earlier edition, only kindergarten through grade 5 were broken down that way.

Both subjects now show progressions more clearly, with charts showing earlier work prepares students for later, more demanding work.

High school mathematics is now organized around six conceptual categories: number and quantity, algebra, functions, geometry, statistics and probability, and modeling. At least at a quick glance, that's easier to grasp than the previous list of ten areas.

The English/language arts standards still emphasize research and argument, but the major stands are simplified to reading, writing, speaking and listening, and language standards (which includes both formal rules and an understanding of the craft and choices involved in effective communication.)

The "exemplar" texts still offer a robust list that can give both teachers and parents an intuitive sense of the level of text complexity that students should tackle. Gone, though, is the special note saying that six specific historic texts should be read by all students. Taking that out makes it consistently clear that all the specific books, poems, and speeches are examples rather than mandates.

I do see the point of that last change, but I still find it a bit sad.  As work moves on to setting history standards, I hope we can agree that the Declaration of Independence and the "I Have A Dream" speech are not examples that can be replaced by other examples: they're giant features of our civic terrain that students need to know as well as they know the Atlantic Ocean, the Rocky Mountains, the directions of the compass, and the cycle of the seasons.

History reading, science reading, and shared responsibility for literacy

In the new draft of the common core standards, the subject formerly known as "English/Language Arts" has become "English Language Arts and Literacy in History/Social Studies & Science."

That's because the draft models a bolder, deeper understanding of what students must know and be able to do to be ready for college and careers.   The introduction to the draft explains:
Literacy standards specific to history/social studies and science for grade 6 and above are predicated on teachers in these areas using their unique disciplinary expertise to help students meet the particular challenges of reading, writing, speaking, listening, and language in their respective fields.
Part of the motivation behind the interdisciplinary approach to literacy promulgated by the Standards is extensive research establishing the need for college- and career-ready students to be proficient in reading complex informational text independently in a variety of content areas. Most of the required reading in college and workforce training programs is informational in structure and challenging in content; postsecondary education programs typically provide students with both a higher volume of such reading than is generally required in K–12 schools and comparatively little scaffolding.
We said we wanted deeper, more competitive standards, and this element definitely calls on our students and schools to aim higher.

Draft K-12 standards are available now! Feedback welcome through April 2.

At last, the draft common core standards for each grade level are available for public comment.  You can:
  • download and comment on the English/language arts draft here.
  • download and comment on the mathematics document here.
  • share your thoughts with me and other readers by clicking the word comments below. (I'd love to know what readers see as pluses and minuses.)
I'll be sharing my thoughts as I work through the document.


The official press release from the National Governors Association calls for comments to be submitted by April 2 and says that "The standards are expected to be finalized in early Spring."

What did House A&R just say?

The SEEK base guarantee per pupil would go down for 2010-11 and then up a bit for 2011-12 under the bill reported out yesterday by the House Appropriation and Revenue Committee:
The bill does not mandate the two instructional days added in 2007-08.  That means that districts can drop back to 175 student learning days and 185 teacher contract days.  In the current fiscal environment, that will mean allow most districts actually must drop those two days.

Meanwhile, the state share of SEEK base funding would go down more than $200 million next year and up only $9 million the next year:

Why does the state total funding look different from the base guarantee?  It's because under the SEEK formula, the state does not pay the full guarantee.  Instead, each district must first contribute 30¢ for each $100 of taxable property. The state then adds what is needed to fund the base guarantee amount and provide "add-on" funding for students with additional learning challenges.

In effect, House A&R is counting on local revenue to rise.  If local taxes pay a larger share of the guarantee, the state can pay less.  And for next year, the budget bill that just passed out of committee does indeed plan for the state to pay less.

As always, the bill coming from the House Committee is sure to undergo multiple amendments before the budget is finalized.


Notes for detail lovers: The 2010-11 state share of SEEK base funding shown above includes $182 million that will actually come from the federal government under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act--also known as the stimulus bill. The 2008-09 and 2009-10 state shares of SEEK come from Department of Education files and reflect the total calculated SEEK base guarantee amount for all districts minus the local district 30¢ contribution.

Monday, March 8, 2010

Achievement gap targets: law or fraud on the public?

I woke up this morning to an account of brave Americans marching forty-five years ago to insist that the right to vote--long enshrined in the Constitution--would become reality rather than fraud. I decided it was time to say that Kentucky, in the past decade, had fallen painfully short of its own commitment to walk steadily toward educational equity.

In 2002, Kentucky passed Senate Bill 168 on achievement gaps.  As originally written, the law specified that:
  • The Department of Education was report to each school on disaggregated results by race, gender, disability, English proficiency, and participation in the federal free and reduced price lunch program.
  • Each school council was to agree with its superintendent and board on two-year targets to eliminate those gaps.
  • Each local board would decide if its schools met those targets two years later.
  • If a school missed a target, the superintendent would have to approve the school's plans for professional development and extended school services.
  • If a school missed the same target twice, the commissioner of education would have to approve the entire school improvement plan.
That process was to repeat in two-year cycles, so that fall 2004 would be the first time superintendents would have approval authority and fall 2006 the first time the commissioner would.   Fall 2008 would be another occasion for commissioner approval of schools that had twice fallen short.

The idea was to be impatient about solving the problem, with just one cycle of councils having independent  responsibility, one cycle of shared council and central office responsibility, and then seriously shared council, district, and KDE responsibility.

2009's Senate Bill 1 appears to ratchet up the level of impatience, calling for one-year targets and one-year cycles of moving power to higher levels.

Only, I don't believe anything in that law is happening consistently across the state.

Why not?

Because I have seen too many school plans with no gap targets and too many with targets defined in a way that would make it impossible for a school board to decide whether the target was met or not.

Realizing I might have missed a meaningful change in the last couple of years, I chose ten districts at random, and checked on-line for their high schools' school improvement plans.

Two high schools had plans available with 2010 numerical targets that allow the law to be implemented:
  • Letcher County Central High School is aiming for “a free/reduced meal student index of 76 in 2010; and a students with disabilities index of 66 in 2010”
  • Washington County High School's commitment is that "60% of the students in the Free & Reduced lunch subgroup will score Proficient or Distinguished in Math on the 2010 KCCT."
I found three more high schools that describe 2010 targets, but in unclear or unspecific ways that will not allow the law to be applied:
  • Bardstown High School's target is  that “By May 2010, 10% of students who did not meet proficiency of Bardstown High School's NCLB subgroups will reach their NCLB math proficiency target of 59.88 as measured on the Kentucky Core Content Test.”
  • Owensboro High School says it will “Reduce racial and SES achievement gaps by 10% annually.”  That could mean too many things: is it about the gap in percent proficient in each subject, by scale scores in each subject, by an index, or by another number? The multiple possible meanings end up  with no clear way to say whether the targets are met or not.
  • Fulton Independent has a district plan because they operate as a single-school district. Their plan says “To eliminate significant achievement gaps for all disaggregated categories at all grade levels as measured by the 2010 KCCT assessment.”  As with the Owensboro goals, that could mean too many different things. 
Two schools had 2010 plans that listed no gap targets at all:
  • Henry County High School
  • Russell High School
Three did not have 2010 plans or have not made them available on their websites
  • Campbellsville High School did not appear to have a plan on line.
  • Dawson Springs had a link for improvement plans, but the school plans listed were for 2004-06.
  • Meade County had a link for school plans, but the link for the high school downloaded the district plan.
What does this mean? The simple thing it means that only one-fifth of the schools I checked had published targets clear enough to allow the law to be implemented.

The larger thing it means that KDE has not taken serious responsiblity for the law getting implemented. In 2006, if the Commissioner had taken his duty to approve plans seriously, he would also have noticed how many targets were too vague, and he could have insisted on improvement. In 2008, he could have done the same thing. The fact that so many targets are too vague to enforce in 2010 is clear proof that the law has not been taken seriously since 2002.

Originally, I had my doubts about SB 168, because No Child Left Behind had already set goals for reducing gaps and Kentucky's SBDM law already required council plans to reduce gaps.  When the time for committee votes came, though, and I had to speak for the Kentucky Association of School Councils, I couldn't bring myself to speak against a sincere effort to tackle the terrible gaps that weaken so many individual students and with them our shared life as a community and our future as a state.

On the Edmund Pettus Bridge in 1965, there were three possible roles: you could be a marcher moving forward for freedom, or you could bar the marchers' way, or you could be a by-stander who let justice go on waiting and your neighbors go on getting bloodied.

Kentucky achievement gaps are not the same as the right to vote, but they are not an entirely separate issue in the effort to live out the true meaning of our creed.  In Kentucky, now, I think we should stop being bystanders.  We should either walk forward seriously to implement SB 168 or replace it with a different but equally firm commitment on educating all children and walk forward seriously to implement that.

Side notes on the schools I selected: First, I was quite impressed by other features of the plans I found, especially in their commitment to formative assessment and collaboration around improving student work.  Letcher County Central's plan struck me as especially solid work.  Second, to choose districts,  I rolled three dice, turned up a thirteen, took Campbellsville as the thirteenth district alphabetically, counted off every 17th district after that, and looped back around at the end to select Bardstown. And finally, I'll be happy to update this post if I missed anything I should have included about the improvement plans for the schools I included.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Kentucky's RTTT status makes sense under the RTTT rules

Kentucky is one of sixteen finalists in the competition for $4 billion in Race to the Top grants.  I've spotted some bloggers who find that odd (here and here, for example). It isn't odd at all.  Consider this overview of how the 500 possible points in the RTTT scoring system are divided up, with more detail available here.

States that earned 400 or more of those points became finalists this week. 

Kentucky's score has not been published, but it's no surprise that it was above the 400 mark.

Kentucky lost some points for not having charter schools,  but there are many other areas where we likely got all or most of the points available:
  • On standards, we have the strongest commitment in the country to using the common core.
  • On assessment, we passed SB 1 and committed to revising our testing to match those standards almost a year ago. 
  • On lowest-achieving schools, we strengthened our intervention options with new legislation and regulations adopted in January.
  • On data systems, the Department committed to rapid upgrades, and higher education co-signed the commitment. 
  • On teachers and leaders, the Department offered a serious plan on more constructive evaluations, and the Education Professional Standards Board is well on its way to strengthening teacher preparation,  education masters degree programs, and principal preparation.
  • On funding, we have more stable, more equitable resources than most states in the union.
  • Under success factors, we brought maximum possible local support for the application: 174 of 174 superintendents, 174 of 174 school board chairs, and 153 of 153 local teachers' union leaders.
My guess is that among the finalists, some are considerably closer to the 500 maximum than we are--and having charters will be one of their advantages.

That means that in the upcoming presentations to win a first-round grant, Kentucky must make a strong pitch for our strengths, starting with the clarity, energy, and unity built into our plan.   Other states may have promised everything imaginable.  We've promised less--especially on charters--but we've made promises we intend to keep.

Small side note: the current competition really is for an even $4 billion. An additional $350 million budgeted for Race to the Top will be awarded in a separate competition for high quality assessments.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

HB 190: an important starting point for preschool access

On the one hand, a hard recession means a very hard state budget process.  On the other hand, good work is underway to prepare for better days ahead, especially in the area of pre-K education.

House Bill 190 sets a goal of making voluntary, quality preschool accessible for every three- and four-year-old, and creates a framework for reaching that goal.  Without asking for a current appropriation, it carefully organized the key steps Kentucky should take as revenue becomes available.

The central idea is grants to support community plans to expand preschool access, looking for cooperation between schools, Head Start programs, and "community-based child-care providers."  The grants will focus on supporting preschool for children from families with incomes up to 200 percent of the federal poverty level (currently about $44,000 for a family of four).

When it's possible to fully fund the effort, more than 21,000 additional Kentucky children will be better prepared for a strong start on their educations and their futures.

HB 190 was approved by the House of Representatives yesterday and will now move on to the Senate for consideration.  You can read the official bill summary here and--on that same page--you can download the bill itself by clicking on the blue underlined version of the bill number.  The Prichard Committee would also love to send you updates on this and related Strong Start early-childhood efforts: click here to let them know you want to participate.

Familiar vision, dramatically different approach to higher education

With first-generation learners, it is critical to connect with them personally, customize the learning to their needs, offer unwavering support, and respect their personal story and the learning that comes with it.
Thats from Inside Higher Ed's interview with Peter Smith, senior vice president for academic strategies and development at Kaplan Higher Education, and it's the kind of commitment that will always get my attention.

I'll admit that I was predisposed not to expect that sort of thinking from "one of the largest for-profit providers of postsecondary education in the United States," as the organization describes itself here.  But Smith backs it up in the interview with thinking specific to Kaplan's strategy, including this:
At Kaplan Higher Education, we do have some fairly traditional practices, but we also have the capacity to innovate, develop, and continuously improve. For instance, if we want to implement diagnostics in the post-enrollment process, we can do so and then evaluate, refine, and improve our processes. The traditional model lacks this type of nimbleness and flexibility. Without the constraints inherent in the traditional model, we can model emerging best practices, help define them and, in effect, help lead the change we seek. 
And also:
Students are rarely asked, in depth, what they want from their college education and are almost never engaged in an ongoing conversation about it with someone who can affect their higher education experience. Until institutions personally connect the learner with the curriculum and the college experience, the learner is vulnerable. And the “at risk” learner is always more vulnerable.
 Yes, the full interview is worth a read.

Kentucky is an RTTT finalist (congratulations all around)!

Fresh from Politics K-12:
And the highly anticipated Round One finalists are...

Colorado, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, and Tennessee.
Next step is presentations in Washington, with first round winners announced in April.

Monday, March 1, 2010

If they aren't college-ready, why are they collecting college degrees?

Over the last five years, the ACT has consistently reported very few Kentucky students meeting their science benchmark for college readiness, which is a demanding 24 on a 0-36 scale.  As shown in the chart below, we've only once had more than 9,000 students reach that mark in a high school graduating class.  And yet, over the same five years, we've consistently given out more than 14,000 associate and bachelor degrees.
This is an imperfect method of raising the issue.  A much better way would be to use higher education data files to take each year's graduates and see how many brought a 24 on the science ACT with them when they entered.  Better still would be to show those results separating graduates based on whether they completed high school in a public or private setting in Kentucky or another state. 

However, I'm stuck using published data.  This sandlot method strongly suggests that quite large numbers of Kentucky residents who are collecting college degrees are doing it without meeting the ACT's definition of college-ready in science.

This issue begs for thoughtful discussion and would benefit greatly from sustained analysis of data on individual students.  Again, the key question is:  If Kentucky students aren't college-ready, why are they collecting so many college degrees?

Data sources: the science benchmark numbers come from the annual ACT state profiles available here, with 2005 being the first year for which I could locate the counts of students scoring 24 or above.  The degree numbers come from the CPE report on 2009 May Graduates, with the 2009 numbers being labeled as "preliminary."

Can earlier college and later dropouts fit together?

Earlier, I estimated that raising the dropout age to 18 would mean adding almost 10,000 students to our public schools, at a cost of around $75 million--plus the costs of adding classroom space to accommodate them.

Today, writing about proposals to let student test out of high school earlier, I saw a potential solution.  If 8,000 students finished high school a year early and 2,000 more finished two years early, that would free both the space and the money to serve the added students we want to keep in school.

I should, of course, add some cautions.

On the dropout side,  my estimate of 10,000 prevented dropouts is only an estimate, and it's  based only on students who are tracked as dropping out.  That is, I assumed that several thousand students who somehow evaporate between grade 8 and grade 12 will not be found and added to the count.

On the early-exit side, my numbers are just guesswork about how many students might qualify to finish early and how many of those would want to do so: I haven't seen any evidence to support those guesses.

Finally, and most important, a responsible early-exit plan requires a robust assessment, one that gives a sturdy indication that students really are college-and-career-ready.  Work has begun to create that kind of test, but it's far from ready for broad application in  major life-decisions by Kentucky teenagers.

What shall we do about senior year?

In Sunday's NYT Magazine, Walter Kirn suggests:
If senior year were to vanish from our high schools, either completely or in part, would its infamous excesses, feats of sloth, dances and stretches of absenteeism shift to junior year? To some degree. But what also might happen is that the education process, if it was shortened and compressed some, might help kids think more clearly about their paths in life and set out on them on the right foot instead of waiting to shape up later on.
That sounds familiar. The Prichard Committee's 2005 report on High Achieving High Schools argued that:
The senior year is a special problem. The last year of high school is often a time when students fall behind because, having accumulated the credits they need for graduation, they choose easy electives, outside activities and paid employment instead of challenging academic work. The system as it now exists does not link the senior year with what lies ahead. A wasted senior year means diminished chances of success in postsecondary education or work.
The Prichard recommendations to redeem senior year included:
  • Stronger high school graduation requirements, to include an added half-credit in social studies and two years of a foreign language along with firmer specification of the mathematics and science to be studied.
  • A service-learning requirement for graduation.
  • End-of-course exams to set a consistent level of rigor statewide in key courses.
  • A new push to give students credit for demonstrated proficiency, freeing them from the seat time mandate of the standard Carnegie unit.
  • Expanded opportunities for college-level work during high school, to include both dual-enrollment opportunities and Advanced Placement/International Baccalaureate programs.
Click here to download the complete report.

The Kirn piece argues that students should also be allowed and encouraged to finish high school early, as soon as they have the right level of skill to move on to further education or employment.  He cites the National Center on Education and the Economy's push for board exams that would allow an early exit for high school, along with Kentucky Commissioner Terry Holliday's description of the effort as "“move on when ready.” 

As the parent of two Kentucky students who collected a semester or more of college credit while in high school and a third who's heading that way, I think it's clear that not every student needs four years of high school to be ready.

As a citizen watching the overall data on student performance, I think it's also clear that many students need a full four years of high school--and better, more rigorous, more supportive high school than we're currently offering.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Speaker Stumbo's tough words on higher education costs, results

"What I'm going to tell the college presidents is that the legislature expects better management and better results," Stumbo said.

State lawmakers are looking to balance a $1.2 billion budget shortfall with a 2 percent cut to public universities and colleges in 2011 and flat funding in 2012. The move would save the state about $40 million over the biennium.

Stumbo said if the legislature restores funding to higher education, "We ought to make them hold the tuition levels at the same levels that they are right now" and require them to improve their graduation rates.

"We don't have standards of performance in higher education now, and that needs to change," he said.
The Herald-Leader is reporting those comments and more from the weekly press conference shared by House Speaker Greg Stumbo and Senate President David Williams. 

The Speaker may have a point.  The HigherEdInfo website offers comparative data suggesting that there's room for improvement in our system.  For example, it shows Kentucky postsecondary funding as relatively strong among the states, with graphs that show us as:
  • 15th in state and local revenue per full-time equivalent student.
  • 11th in total revenue per full-time equivalent student.
  • 23rd in the share of higher education operating revenue provided by students and their families.
And yet it shows our productivity as distinctly weaker, with graphs showing us as:
  • 34th in percent of full-time students completing an associate degree in three years.
  • 35th in percent or full-time students completing a bachelor degree in six years.
Surely public concern and public discussion are in order any time a state is putting in above average resources to get back below average results.

    Wednesday, February 24, 2010

    Index results for students with disabilities: growth is happening

    Students with disabilities are making more rapid progress than other student groups, though not at the pace needed to reach proficiency by 2014. That result is visible in the newest "transition index" analysis released by the Council for Better Education, the Kentucky Association of School Councils, and the Prichard Committee.

    The graphs below show results for students with disabilities over the last three years, with a projection of results out to 2014 and comparison results for all students.  An index of 100 is equivalent to the average student being proficient in reading, mathematics, science, social studies, and writing.
    The central, easy-to-spot, point is that these students are far behind their peers.  A second point, though, should not be missed: results for students with disabilities are improving faster than results for all students.  For all the justified frustration this data will provoke, do notice that the results are changing.  To me, that suggests that the efforts of educators and parents matter and that steady accountability from the state and federal level matter, too.

    Results for other student groups were released last fall, but a data glitch delayed the analysis for the disability group until this week. The full statewide report and school and district results are here.

    Monday, February 22, 2010

    College readiness work: a bit more on the Gates Foundation investment

    Here are two good sources of added information on the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation's new investments in college readiness

    First, Vicki Phillips and Carina Wong explain the overall strategy in an article on "Tying Together the Common Core of Standards, Instruction, and Assessments"  in the February 2010 Kappan (scroll down to the "Features").  Respectively, they are the Foundation's director of education and its deputy director for College-Ready Work. 

    Second, the Foundation press release from last Thursday, begins:
    The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation today announced 15 grants totaling more than $19.5 million to support the development and testing of prototype classroom assessments and instructional tools in math and literacy to help educators better prepare all students for success beyond high school. The investments are part of the foundation’s support of the effort to build a coherent system of consistent college- and career-ready standards, aligned assessments, and teaching tools to strengthen teacher effectiveness and dramatically improve student achievement.
    The Prichard Committee project blogged here is a piece of this larger effort.

    Prichard Committee to pilot new teaching and testing resources for math: grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation will help fund work

    I'm just catching up on the news from the end of the last week.  An important Prichard Committee release is below:

    LEXINGTON, KY – Teachers in six Kentucky school districts will be among the first in the nation to explore new ways to teach mathematics under a grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to the Prichard Committee for Academic Excellence. The ninth and tenth grade teachers will work with new teaching and testing resources that have been developed by national experts to accelerate students' mastery of mathematics.


    "We’re tremendously excited by this opportunity," said Robert F. Sexton, executive director of the Prichard Committee. "The new materials will help schools implement Kentucky's brand new mathematics standards, tracking each student's level of understanding and developing teaching methods that keep all students moving forward. It's an early look at the kind of professional development all Kentucky teachers will need."


    The new approach—known as "assessment for learning" or "formative assessment"—fits well with legislation passed by the 2009 General Assembly requiring that Kentucky adopt new mathematics standards and develop a new testing approach. The "assessment for learning" approach emphasizes classroom-level activities that provide teachers with better insight into student learning needs. The emphasis is on quickly helping teachers adjust their teaching to help all students reach high standards of learning.


    During intensive professional development sessions, the participating teachers will work with classroom "performance events" that provide immediate information on what part of a topic students already understand and what still needs work. In turn, that will allow teachers to adjust instruction so that all students ultimately master the mathematics being taught.


    "Each performance event will allow teachers to shape future learning," said Ann Shannon, a mathematics researcher with a leading role in the project. "We'll be working on how teachers can quickly address student difficulties, pose follow-up questions that deepen understanding, and ensure that all students end up with a strong grasp of the key concepts they need to master."


    The pilot testing in Kentucky is part of a larger nationwide effort by the Gates Foundation to support the development and testing of prototype math and literacy classroom assessments and instructional tools to help educators better prepare all students for life beyond high school.


    The Prichard Committee has selected the following high schools to participate in the project:
    • Boone County, Conner, Cooper, and Ryle high schools, Boone County
    • Apollo, Beacon, and Daviess County high schools, Daviess County
    • Doss and Iroquois high schools, Jefferson County
    • East Jessamine and West Jessamine high schools in Jessamine County
    • Dixie, Scott, and Simon Kenton high schools in Kenton County
    • Warren Central and Warren East high schools in Warren County
    Eighth-grade mathematics teachers in Daviess County also have been invited to participate in the work.


    The Prichard Committee for Academic Excellence is a nonprofit citizens' organization that works to improve education for all Kentuckians.


    ###

    Thursday, February 18, 2010

    Implementing the new standards and parents with decision-makers.

    The Missing Piece report sets a high bar for schools’ work to engage parents in school decisions, expecting that: “School staff encourages, supports and expects parents to be involved in school improvement decisions and to monitor and assist school improvement.”  

    To avoid misunderstanding, let me emphasize something: the decision-making standard here is about the school’s goals, the school’s strategies, the school’s budget, and the school’s staffing. All those elements will have to be realigned as the new are moved paper to meaningful classroom implementation. Every school has big decisions ahead, distinct from the decisions about individual students that are discussed  in parent-teacher conferences and ARRC meetings.

    Including parents in those schoolwide decisions will yield strategies with better understanding, support, and energy behind them.

    The work starts with the learning opportunities discussed earlier to introduce the standards and discuss their importance.   Beyond that, parents on the council and its committees must work actively alongside educators to develop the school’s strategies. Widening the circle further, all parents must have multiple, meaningful opportunities to explore, question, and suggest improvements to those strategies as they are being developed.

    Helpfully, though, the new standards themselves can work to draw parents into the discussion. Parents are going to be excited by the clearer, shorter statement of what students need to learn at each level, and by the new commitment to equip students to succeed in college and good jobs by the time they leave high school. Our new goals for students, in short, can generate new parent motivation to join in the school’s decisions.

    Higher education funding by institution: the shrinking version and the growing version

    Here's one way to display the state budget for higher education, comparing the FY 2006 budget to the Governor's FY 2012 budget.

    Looking at the General Fund alone, every four-year institution except Kentucky State will lose ground, and the KSU gain is less than $40,000.  KCTCS is slated to gain a bit over $4 million.   If the Governor's budget or something similar is adopted, the institutions as a group will receive about 2 percent less they received 2006, and no help at all with inflation that reduces their buying power.

    Here's another way to look at the budget impact, considering all the revenue shown in state budget documents.  In this version, every institution is expected to see growth, averaging 40 percent and ranging from 12 percent at Kentucky State to 51 percent at the University of Kentucky.

    Of course, neither version accounts for enrollment changes, expanded research, or other changes in how each institution contributes to the state overall.

    Wednesday, February 17, 2010

    Advocacy for every student, college-and-career-readiness for every student

    The Missing Piece approach to parent engagement puts a high value on advocacy, setting this as the standard: "For each student, the school staff identifies and supports a parent or another adult who takes personal responsibility for understanding and speaking for each child’s learning needs."  It describes a school with that commitment as having features like these:
    • School staff ensures every student has a parent and/or another adult who knows how to advocate, or speak up for them, regarding the student’s academic goals and individual needs.
    • Most parents participate actively in student led conferences or other two-way communication about meeting their child’s individual learning needs.
    • Parents report participating actively and effectively in required planning for individual learning, for example, Individual Education Plans, Individual Learning Plans, Gifted Student Plans, 504 Plans, and intervention strategies to ensure college readiness....
    • School staff gives parents clear, complete information on the procedures for resolving concerns and filing complaints, and the council reviews summary data on those complaints to identify needed improvements.
    • School staff ensures that parents and community members are well informed about how to become educational advocates, or how to access a trained educational advocate when needed.
    • As students are identified by school staff as having disabilities or performing at the novice level, additional intentional steps are taken to ensure that parents have the option to use a trained advocate to assist them in speaking for their child’s needs.
    I've spent a lot of time talking with frustrated advocates for individual children: they're pretty much my favorite kind of folks.

    What they want, over and over, is to get a clear commitment on what a child needs to learn and a clear commitment on the steps to make that happen and then (most importantly) follow-through on what goes down in the IEP or the notes from the meeting or the e-mail to spell out what's been discussed.

    The new standards ought to make it easier for advocates to get to the specification of what a child will achieve.  They're shorter, clearer, better broken down into levels of work. Using them, it should be more possible to say students will reach the standards for the grade during the school year, or begin work with a collaborating teacher next week on the two that are proving difficult, or have summer support to get on top of any standards that aren't reached by year's end.

    More importantly, the new standards are custom-made for a different model of teaching.  They're meant to allow every classroom to be designed around meeting the same standard for every student, but doing it by varying means and constant adjustments based on fresh information about individual progress. If that becomes the regular way of doing business, then advocates will have a much simpler job.  If the school day is already  organized around responding to individual needs, the advocates will only need to discuss which particular adjustments will be the best help for a particular student.

    Earlier PrichBlog posts on parent engagement and the new standards are here, here, and here.

    Tuesday, February 16, 2010

    Communication about students using the new college-and-career-ready standards (scaffolding needed!)

    The 2007 Missing Piece report standard for strong communication is that: "Two-way information in many forms flows regularly between school staff and parents about students’ academic achievement and individual needs."

    Kentucky has committed to new English/language arts and mathematics standards, to be shared with many other states, that will be shorter, clearer, and deeper than our past Core Content documents.  The the current drafts of those documents (and lots of other reporting about Kentucky's decision) are available here.

    There's a basic--maybe too basic--level of communication that could happen just with the standards themselves. A teacher could send home a copy of the third grade math standards with notes saying which ones a student mastered, which ones are nearly mastered, and which ones need work.

    That's information, but it doesn't give parents a good idea of next steps.

    Instead, there's going to be a crucial school-level effort after the standards are finalized. The standards are written now for statewide use, but they need to be broken down and restated as a set of steps for students to climb, like a ladder or a scaffold, to reach the standards. Doing the work within each school will ensure that the teachers know their own scaffolding inside and out.

    That will allow teachers to plan their own instruction to move students up the steps. It will also allow them to show both students and parents which step a student has reached, and what work is needed to reach the next step. Parents, in turn, can ask for specifics on how to help and share information on what is and isn't working for their individual children.

    That approach to clear expectations, careful data collection, and confidence-building communication is part of the "balanced assessment" or "assessment for learning" approach that is a regular topic in this blog.

    The new standards are an important starting point, but we can't stop there.  To allow the best communication between parents and and teachers, they should be converted into a scaffolding that makes sense to each school's teachers and that forms a framework for helping both students and parents see how to climb to success.

    Readers may also want to check out Sunday's post on the main ideas in the Missing Piece report and Monday's post on parent learning opportunities and the new standards.

    Kentucky's deficit, bad as it is, is better than most states

    In the map above, white shows the two states without deficits, and blue shows the states with deficits of 19 percent or less.  Kentucky's big financial hole is actually smaller than the many states in olive green (20 to 29 percent) and the smaller group in lime green (30 percent or higher).

    The data is from a recent Center for Budget and Policy Priorities report, and the map is from FiveThirtyEight.

    KCTCS enrollment surge sweeps past university undergraduates

    The fall 2009 headcount for the Kentucky Community and Technical College System was 10 percent higher than 2008 and 69 percent higher than 2000. 

    In fact, KCTCS now serves more learners than the combined bachelor's programs of all eight public universities.  That's a pretty good benchmark of the large role the system now plays in Kentucky higher education.

    The numbers below come from the "Fall Enrollment Report" presented at the February 11 meeting of the Council on Postsecondary Education.

    Monday, February 15, 2010

    Parent learning opportunities to support college-and-career-ready standards

    The Missing Piece report counts parent  learning opportunities as one of the six ways schools ought to engage parents.   Kentucky has committed to new college-and-career-ready standards for students, and it's time to get moving on ways for parents to learn about what's changing.

    I'd suggest several steps for that effort.

    Right now, spread the word about what's coming.  In newsletters, PTA meetings, and elsewhere, it's time to talk up the pending change. As a parent, there are two features of the new standards that strike me as the most important. First, we will see a much more concrete statement of what their students should be able to do as they complete each level of education.  Second, we can see where work at each level is heading: students who move through each level of the standards will finish high school be equipped for college-level work and ready to succeed in jobs with a future.

    Soon, start designing tools for parents to explore the standards when a final edition is released:
    • For starters, the documents for each grade should be available on an accessible, widely publicized website.
    • Second, examples matter.  Right now, the English/language arts draft does a good job of displaying what sort of work students should be able to read at each level.  The mathematics draft, though, could use clearer illustrations of the work students should master.  If those examples are not built into the final edition, expert teachers should construct them quickly.
    • Third, organize it all as activities that can work at PTA meetings, school socials, and other events, and as displays that can catch a parent's eye on the way into the building.  Puzzles, checklists, posters, and videos can all be ways to draw parents into the discussion..
    Those design steps can be done by state or national level organizations.

    And, this fall, make the standards central to parent activities.    Our new expectations are the right centerpiece of all the start-up activities of a new academic year, from registration to home visits and open houses.  They should get the spotlight at multiple school board, school council, and PTA or P.T.O. meetings.

    Early college at Western High School (sounds great!)

    The Jefferson  Community and Technical College and the Jefferson County Schools are finalizing plans to offer college level work at Western High School.   

    At least initially, JCTC faculty will provide the courses that count both toward high school graduation and for credit at the college level.  An option is being built in for Western teachers to do some additional study and start also teaching some of the dual-credit classes.

    The C-J has a long, impressive report on the plan here.

    I'd add one further plus of this plan.  In a district committed to offering students and parents a choice among diverse schools, this option seems likely to get many takers.

    Kentucky education budgets looking at all sources (changes the picture a bit)

    Tthe general fund  education budgets gets lots of discussion, but the graphs below show a more complete picture of the trends by including the other revenues each level receive.  The 2012 numbers reflect the Governor's recommended budget, which is of course likely to be changed by the General Assembly.
    Restricted funds come from user fees--a small amount for P-12, but a big one when it includes the tuition and other amounts students and families pay for higher education. 


    Source notes:

    The FY 2006 numbers come primarily from the FY 2006-08 Budget of the Commonwealth.  The P-12 figures include funding budgeted to the Department of Education, the Education Professional Standards Board, the Kentucky Teachers Retirement System, and the School Facilities Construction Commission.  One exception: The estimated local portion used the Department's file for 2005-06 SEEK Final Summary Data, multiplied each district's total property assessment by its current year levied tax rate, and summed the results.

    The FY 2008 numbers were developed the same way, using the 2008-10 Budget of the Commonwealth and the 2007-08 SEEK data file.

    The FY 2010 numbers were developed the same way, using the Governor's 2010-12 budget proposal and the 2009-10 tentative SEEK data file.

    The FY 2012 numbers come primarily from the Governor's 2010-12 budget proposal.  The Governor's proposed 1.6 percent SEEK guarantee increase appears to rely in part on a 5.8 percent increase in the local 30¢ contribution from FY 2010 to FY 2012, so I applied the same rate of increase to the total local revenue.

    Sunday, February 14, 2010

    Physical activity and Kentucky requirements

    On the one hand, Joan Buchar's argument for physical education in today's Herald-Leader makes an important case for schools to promote healthy habits in all our children.  The issue deserves sustained effort from our state, schools, and families.

    On the other hand, she fails to mention that in Kentucky, every school council serving students in grades K-6 is required to arrange 150 minutes of physical activity for each student.  That requirement is found in KRS 160.345(11), which says:
    Each school council of a school containing grades K-5 or any combination thereof, or if there is no school council, the principal, shall develop and implement a wellness policy that includes moderate to vigorous physical activity each day and encourages healthy choices among students. The policy may permit physical activity to be considered part of the instructional day, not to exceed thirty  minutes per day, or one hundred and fifty minutes per week. Each school council, or if there is no school council, the principal, shall adopt an assessment tool to determine each child's level of physical activity on an annual basis. The council or principal may utilize an existing assessment program. The Kentucky Department of Education shall make available a list of available resources to carry out the provisions of this subsection. The department shall report to the Legislative Research Commission no later than November 1 of each year on how the schools are providing physical activity under this subsection and on the types of physical activity being provided. The policy developed by the school council or principal shall comply with provisions required by federal law, state law, or local board policy.

    Engaging parents in the push to college-and-career-readiness

     Kentucky is moving forward with college-and-career-readiness standards.  48 states are participating in developing those standards, but Kentucky is the first state to start the regulatory process to adopt them, and we'll be among the first to move the standards into our classrooms and our assessments.

    To actually reach the standards, we'll need to add another element: sustained parent engagement.  The Missing Piece of the Proficiency Puzzle (developed in 2007 by the Commissioner's Parent Advisory Council) identifies six key elements of meaningful work to engage those crucial participants:

    1. Relationship-building
    2. Communications
    3. Decision-making
    4. Advocacy
    5. Learning Opportunities
    6. Community Partnerships

    All six elements matter, and in the coming week, I'll think out loud about how Kentucky might get started on using each one to move students toward meeting our new clearer and deeper standards.

    Wednesday, February 10, 2010

    Brilliant: Sharron Oxendine explains the new standards

    Great WKYT video here.

    New college and career ready standards launched: Kentucky on the cutting edge of education improvement

    “This is an historic moment for Kentucky,” said Kentucky Board of Education Chair Joe Brothers. “With the implementation of the Common Core State Standards, teachers and administrators will have a blueprint to move the state forward in P-12 education. This is just the beginning of Kentucky’s next chapter of education reform, and it reflects the mandates of the state’s legislature – specifically, Senate Bill 1 -- and our application for federal Race to the Top funding.”

    “The Common Core Standards come at an opportune time for us at EPSB as we forge ahead to meet the charges set forth by Senate Bill 1,” said EPSB Chair Lorraine Williams. “To truly make a difference in Kentucky’s students’ ability to demonstrate what they know and are able to do and to make them more competitive in the marketplace, it is a refreshing move to narrow the number of standards taught at each level. ESPB is excited to be part of this cutting edge initiative and looks forward to working with our university partners to ensure that our undergraduate and graduate teacher preparation programs embrace the Common Core Standards and prepare a stronger workforce capable of teaching the curriculum to a deeper, more rigorous level.”

    “Kentucky is once again at the forefront in education reform,” said CPE Chair Paul Patton. “I am very pleased with the level of cooperation and commitment by Kentucky’s policy and education leaders in the development of these draft content standards. Consistent academic standards, aligned to college and work expectations, will help our students reach higher levels of success.”

    Launched in 2009, the Common Core State Standards Initiative is a state-led effort coordinated by the National Governors Association Center for Best Practices (NGA Center) and the Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO). Governors and state commissioners of education from 48 states, two territories and the District of Columbia committed to developing a common core of state standards in English/language arts and mathematics for grades K-12.

    CCSSO and NGA plan to release the final version of the standards in early spring. 

    All that from the official press release out minutes ago.

    AP growth for Kentucky and Nation

    In 2009, almost 11 percent of Kentucky high school graduates earned a score of 3 or higher on at least one Advanced Placement test, likely qualifying them to receive college credit for their high school work. That puts us 3oth among the states, up from 31st in 2008 and 37th in 2004.

    $71.5+ cost to raise the dropout age to 18

    House Bill 301 would raise Kentucky's dropout age from 16 to 18 by 2014. At the current level of SEEK and benefits funding, I estimate that doing that would require more than $71.5 million in added resources.

    The dollars would well spent, yielding an important return both to the students and the state in future economic strength.

    Nevertheless, the money won't grow on trees. The costs of keeping those students in school must either be added to state P-12 funding or subtracted from services districts provide to other students.

    For number lovers, I'll explain my method after the jump. [Update: my first attempt to use the "jump" function isn't working, so instead I'll put the explanation in small print below]

    STEP 1: ADDED ENROLLMENT
    The most recent statewide dropout figures show:
    • 6,297 dropouts in 2006-07.
    • 6,729 dropouts in 2007-08.
    Students who were 16 or over in 2006-07 would be 18 two years later, so I assumed that half of those students would drop out. As a result, I assumed that under House Bill 301, Kentucky schools would have:
    • 9,878 additional students enrolled.
    STEP 2: ATTENDANCE ADJUSTMENT
    Kentucky funds schools based on average daily attendance, not enrollment. For 2007-08, the statewide attendance rate was 94.12 percent. Applying that to enrollment, I estimated that Kentucky schools would have:
    • 9,302 students in average daily attendance.
    STEP 3: PER PUPIL FUNDING
    Under the 2009-10 SEEK formula, schools are guaranteed an average of:
    • $3,866 per pupil in base funding.
    • $5,285 once the add-ons for special needs and transportation are added to the base.
    • $6,078 once Tier I additional funding is added to base and add-ons.
    Those figures include both state and local funding.
    STEP 4: BENEFITS FUNDING
    For 2009-10, Kentucky provides state funding of:
    • $362.7 million for retirement benefits for certified staff in schools and districts.
    • $577.7 million for health benefits for all staff in schools and districts.
    • $940.4 million total for benefits.
    • $1,606 for benefits per pupil in average daily attendance.
    • $7,684 per pupil adding benefits to the earlier $6,078.
    STEP 5: ESTIMATED NEEDED FUNDING
    My total estimate is:
    • 9,302 students in average daily attendance, multiplied by...
    • $7,684 in per pupil funding, to get...
    • $71,474,246 in needed additional funding.
    FACILITIES
    That estimate leaves out a major facilities issue: serving 9,878 more students would require 318 additional classrooms even at the high school maximum of 31 students per class.


    TIER II UNEQUALIZED LOCAL FUNDING
    The estimate includes the local contribution to the SEEK base and the local revenue needed to qualify for Tier I equalization. Most districts now raise additional revenue--called Tier II--that does not qualify for state equalization, but I do not have a good estimate of that revenue at my fingertips.


    UNTRACKED DROPOUTS
    That estimate uses only official reported dropouts. Based on comparing eighth grade student counts to graduates four years later, roughly 3,000 students a year seem to disappear without officially dropping out. My estimate assumed that those students would continue to be "lost or stolen or strayed."


    RETRACTING AN EARLIER ESTIMATE
    Last March, I offered an estimated cost of $29 million for a similar bill. That estimate was far too low because:
    • I assumed that raising the dropout rate by two years would only keep one year's worth of dropouts in school.
    • I used only SEEK base funding and the benefits costs, leaving out the add-ons, the Tier 1 state funding, and the Tier 1 local funding.

    Special education teacher preparation questions

    In the 2009 Teacher Quality Yearbook, the preparation of special education teachers is a report element worth noting. The report argues that:
    1. The state should require that teacher preparation programs provide a broad liberal arts program of study to elementary special education candidates. All elementary special education candidates should have preparation in the content areas of math, science, English, social studies and fine arts and should be required to pass a subject-matter test for licensure.

    2. The state should require that teacher preparation programs graduate secondary special education teacher candidates who are “highly qualified” in at least two subjects. The most efficient route for these candidates to become adequately prepared to teach multiple subjects may be to earn the equivalent of two subject area minors and pass tests in those areas.

    3. The state should customize a “HOUSSE” route for new secondary special education teachers to help them achieve highly qualified status in all the subjects they teach.
    Kentucky and 24 other states are not doing any of those things. Only six meet the elementary standard, and only 15 meet the secondary standard. Only 14 use the HOUSSE option, short for "high, objective, uniform state standard of evaluation" and defined here as allowing teachers to demonstrate subject knowledge through " a combination of proven teaching experience, professional development, and knowledge in the subject acquired over time through working in the field."

    While I'm not comfortable with the full Yearbook list of expectations, these special education standards do seem worth considering. Of course, they effectively say that special education teachers need pretty much the full background of other teachers plus the added knowledge and skills to work with students with additional needs. If we want that added preparation from teachers who are already taking on added challenge, it seems to me that we're going to have to commit to give them added compensation as well.

    Teacher policy grades from NCTQ

    The 2009 State Teacher Quality Yearbook is out, grading each state against a long, demanding set of standards that the National Council on Teacher Quality sees as needed. Here's a snapshot of how all state scores. Kentucky is in the top half of states, but clearly not doing the full array of things the Council recommends.


    I'm not sure I agree with the full set of standards in the yearbook, but it does give a good overview of what states are doing and how it compares to the authors' view of what would strengthen teaching nationwide.

    Tuesday, February 9, 2010

    Kentucky moving forward on college ready standards

    Art Jester has great Business Lexington reporting up on tomorrow's big meeting to commit Kentucky to the common core standards for college and career readiness--and on why that step is so important. To lure you into reading the whole thing, here are just a few snippets:
    "We will be the first state in the nation to signal our leadership in education reform," said Kentucky Education Commissioner Terry Holliday.
    * * *
    As Rep. Carl Rollins (D-Midway) put it, the common standards will enable "everyone coming together on the same page" nationwide to determine what students should learn at each grade level.

    Rollins, the chairman of the state House Education Committee, said the common standards are "real improvements" that should lead to the development of "new national tests with national standards."

    "We're going in the right direction," said Rollins, a state financial aid official and a former Midway mayor who has a doctorate in education.
    * * *
    "It's very exciting that Kentucky is a leader moving in this direction," said Fayette County Schools Superintendent Stu Silberman. "The narrowing and deepening of the standards is something I think is going to be good for our kids and teachers because it's going to allow us to spend more in-depth time on the core content. It feels good that Kentucky is on the forefront as a national leader again."

    Is principal selection about to change?

    The House Education Committee has reported out House Bill 322 on principal selection. Since I watched on-line, I don't yet have a copy of the substitute language added during the committee meeting, but I"m confident I've got the main idea.

    Since 1990, Kentucky law has called for school councils to select principals, with the big debate being over the role of the superintendent in deciding who could be considered for the job.

    The Department long advised that the council only got to consider qualified applicants, and that only people the superintendent recommended were qualified. If a superintendent recommended only two people, the council needed to choose from that pair.

    The Kentucky Supreme Court, however, rejected that interpretation in 2004, and read the law to say that when councils ask for additional applicants, the superintendent cannot hold back applicants based on his or her judgment about whether they can be effective.

    Today's committee vote was on language that would let the superintendent submit three names to the council and give the council three weeks to choose between them.

    I'm not opposed to the change. Student success requires highly effective principals. To be effective, new principals must start work with the support both of their councils and their superintendents. The method in the amended bill will provide that shared support, so I think it's okay.

    On the other hand, I'm not excited about it. That's because I know that most principals already come in with strong support from their superintendents.

    First, the superintendents I admire most invest deeply in working with their councils, and when it's time to select principals, they have substantial influence on the results.

    Second, many potential principals know they can't succeed without strong support, so they don't even apply if they won't have the superintendent's backing. I've seen two kinds of exceptions. One is that a principal with local roots may try to wait out a superintendent who isn't from the area, The other is that in the largest districts, principals don't expect to spend much time working closely with the superintendent, so they seem to be less concerned about making sure that relationship will be a warm one. In general, though, principals only go where they're wanted, and that includes being wanted by the superintendent.

    Knowing all of that, if HB 322 becomes law, I do not think it will change the outcome in most principal selections.

    (For readers who do not already know, I worked for the Kentucky Association of School Councils from its founding until 2006.)

    Monday, February 8, 2010

    High school math strands in the core standards

    My high school math career consisted of three conventionally named courses--Algebra I, Geometry, and Algebra 3--and then another course I think was called "A-cubed-T" for advanced analytic algebra and trigonometry. The high school that offered that course would happily have placed me in calculus the next year, but didn't quite want to call it "pre-calculus."

    In the new draft of core standards being developed for shared use in 48 states, I'm not seeing titles of high school courses or grades when students should take each one. Instead, the document explains early that:
    The high school standards .... are organized under headings of the College and Career Ready Standards for Mathematics: Expressions, Equations, Functions, Coordinates, Modeling, Statistics, Probability, and Geometry.... This design necessitates a future effort to develop course sequences (either traditional or integrated).
    The benefit of that approach may be that the experts did not see one clearly superior order in which the high school mathematics content should be taught, but did agree on what math students needed to master to be ready to succeed as they head to college or into the workplace. While remembering that these elements could change substantially in the next draft, here's what appears under those headings:

    Expressions
    Seeing structure in expressions
    The arithmetic of polynomials and rational functions

    Equations
    Building equations to model relations between quantities
    Reasoning with equations and inequalities

    Functions
    Interpreting functions
    Building functions
    Linear vs. exponential behavior
    Trigonometric functions

    Coordinates
    Expressing geometric properties with equations
    Vectors and matrices
    Complex numbers

    Modeling
    The modeling cycle and general tools
    Modeling with geometry, equations, functions, probability, and statistics

    Statistics
    Summarizing and interpreting categorical, count, and measurement data
    Making inferences and justifying conclusions drawn from data

    Probability
    Modeling random events with finite sample spaces
    Experimenting and simulating to model probabilities
    Using probability to make decisions

    Geometry
    Triangle Congruence
    Similarity, Right Triangles and Trigonometry
    Circles
    Axiomatic systems
    Trigonometry of general triangles
    Geometric measurement and dimension
    As a final note, EdWeek has reported that:
    Several reviewers said writers and reviewers of the math draft were trying to work out possible differences between the skills that should be required of all students, and only of those aiming for college majors or careers in math or science.
    For some of the items listed above, I don't know enough to take an informed side in the debate, but it does seem important for the experts to work through that question with care.

    Math for each grade in the common standards

    The new grade-by-grade draft of the core standards lays out what students should master each year from kindergarten through eighth grade. Here, reformatted from the last page of the draft, is a thumbnail version of that progression:
    The full array of subjects for each grade is laid out in three pages of text, with enough detail to help parents work out what's included under those mathematical terms.

    The plan is for the final version to start each grade with a section on "Developing Coherent Understanding." That looks as though it may explain how the topics within a grade reinforce one another and build on past work, but in this draft, the text below that heading just says "[Temporarily removed for editing.]"

    Over the years, I've heard many parents wish for an overview of what to expect year by year, both to plan extra help for their children and to have a sense of whether classroom instruction is falling behind. This draft offers a pretty robust response to that desire.

    Sunday, February 7, 2010

    Enrollment surge, transfer woes for KCTCS

    On the one hand, the Kentucky Community and Technical College Sustem has 18 percent more students than it had this time a year ago. That's an impressive step step up. If the system receives no increase in state funding, it makes sense that it will have to choose between cutting enrollment or cutting services.

    On the other hand, legislation to smooth the way for students to move from two-year to o four-year schools has hit a snag. After the bill breezed through the House, concerns have surfaced in the Senate over proposed rules on transfers and degree requirements. For example, Shirley Willihnganze at the University of Louisville is quoted as anticipating "trouble with a number of accrediting agencies that require more hours than that for a degree."

    Both stories come from Herald-Leader reporting.

    Digital competence, civics, and the common core

    Vicki Phillips of the Gates Foundation wrote in October that:
    The explosion of media and technology has added remarkable opportunities for gaining and sharing knowledge, but it also has made it all the more important that students master the core skills of gathering and evaluating evidence. Reading and writing with independence and confidence will remain master arts in the information age.
    As I blogged the research skills built in to the new draft of the common core standards for writing, that comment kept going through my head.

    The current technological revolution raises the bar for citizenship: with vast information at our fingertips, our new struggle will be to evaluate and use that information well.

    In response, the draft standards raise the bar for students, and call on schools to equip students for exactly that type of work. It's time to push forward on developing those "master arts" at a high level for every student.