The 2007 Missing Piece report standard for strong communication is that: "Two-way information in many forms flows regularly between school staff and parents about students’ academic achievement and individual needs."
Kentucky has committed to new English/language arts and mathematics standards, to be shared with many other states, that will be shorter, clearer, and deeper than our past Core Content documents. The the current drafts of those documents (and lots of other reporting about Kentucky's decision) are available here.
There's a basic--maybe too basic--level of communication that could happen just with the standards themselves. A teacher could send home a copy of the third grade math standards with notes saying which ones a student mastered, which ones are nearly mastered, and which ones need work.
That's information, but it doesn't give parents a good idea of next steps.
Instead, there's going to be a crucial school-level effort after the standards are finalized. The standards are written now for statewide use, but they need to be broken down and restated as a set of steps for students to climb, like a ladder or a scaffold, to reach the standards. Doing the work within each school will ensure that the teachers know their own scaffolding inside and out.
That will allow teachers to plan their own instruction to move students up the steps. It will also allow them to show both students and parents which step a student has reached, and what work is needed to reach the next step. Parents, in turn, can ask for specifics on how to help and share information on what is and isn't working for their individual children.
That approach to clear expectations, careful data collection, and confidence-building communication is part of the "balanced assessment" or "assessment for learning" approach that is a regular topic in this blog.
The new standards are an important starting point, but we can't stop there. To allow the best communication between parents and and teachers, they should be converted into a scaffolding that makes sense to each school's teachers and that forms a framework for helping both students and parents see how to climb to success.
Readers may also want to check out Sunday's post on the main ideas in the Missing Piece report and Monday's post on parent learning opportunities and the new standards.
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query missing piece. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query missing piece. Sort by date Show all posts
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Saturday, June 12, 2010
Summer Newsletter is a feast!
The Summer issue of Prichard Perspectives is now available on-line, with an irresistable menu of news on education issues and the Committee's efforts:• Pilot program makes math a ‘productive struggle’ (with details on the Gates math work)
• Pew grant extends Prichard Pre-K work
• Brant promoting Pre-K business leadership council
• Pre-K expansion bill dies in legislature
• Policy Center sees Kentucky students rising
• Harvard report spotlights Commonwealth Institute
• [Missing Piece] Workshops spread across Kentucky
• [Authentic Parent Engagement] Workshop will equip parent-leadership trainers
• Moberly honored with Award of Excellence
• Sexton addresses Bellarmine grads
• Heine joins meeting with Duncan
• Privett to join Prichard work
• Sexton, staff share Prichard lessons in Baltimore
• Walter Baker dies; former lawmaker, Prichard member
Enjoy it all here, and don't miss the lovely reminders that you can support the Committee's work with a donation, and honor educators who have made a difference in your life.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Implementing the new standards and parents with decision-makers.
The Missing Piece report sets a high bar for schools’ work to engage parents in school decisions, expecting that: “School staff encourages, supports and expects parents to be involved in school improvement decisions and to monitor and assist school improvement.”
To avoid misunderstanding, let me emphasize something: the decision-making standard here is about the school’s goals, the school’s strategies, the school’s budget, and the school’s staffing. All those elements will have to be realigned as the new are moved paper to meaningful classroom implementation. Every school has big decisions ahead, distinct from the decisions about individual students that are discussed in parent-teacher conferences and ARRC meetings.
Including parents in those schoolwide decisions will yield strategies with better understanding, support, and energy behind them.
The work starts with the learning opportunities discussed earlier to introduce the standards and discuss their importance. Beyond that, parents on the council and its committees must work actively alongside educators to develop the school’s strategies. Widening the circle further, all parents must have multiple, meaningful opportunities to explore, question, and suggest improvements to those strategies as they are being developed.
Helpfully, though, the new standards themselves can work to draw parents into the discussion. Parents are going to be excited by the clearer, shorter statement of what students need to learn at each level, and by the new commitment to equip students to succeed in college and good jobs by the time they leave high school. Our new goals for students, in short, can generate new parent motivation to join in the school’s decisions.
To avoid misunderstanding, let me emphasize something: the decision-making standard here is about the school’s goals, the school’s strategies, the school’s budget, and the school’s staffing. All those elements will have to be realigned as the new are moved paper to meaningful classroom implementation. Every school has big decisions ahead, distinct from the decisions about individual students that are discussed in parent-teacher conferences and ARRC meetings.
Including parents in those schoolwide decisions will yield strategies with better understanding, support, and energy behind them.
The work starts with the learning opportunities discussed earlier to introduce the standards and discuss their importance. Beyond that, parents on the council and its committees must work actively alongside educators to develop the school’s strategies. Widening the circle further, all parents must have multiple, meaningful opportunities to explore, question, and suggest improvements to those strategies as they are being developed.
Helpfully, though, the new standards themselves can work to draw parents into the discussion. Parents are going to be excited by the clearer, shorter statement of what students need to learn at each level, and by the new commitment to equip students to succeed in college and good jobs by the time they leave high school. Our new goals for students, in short, can generate new parent motivation to join in the school’s decisions.
Sunday, October 11, 2009
Some additions to those levers
Rereading my "Four Levers for Chairman Brothers" post, I realized that some things that I took for granted maybe weren't obvious in how I set out my ideas. Here come some added notes to that analysis, connecting it to issues I've blogged about often over the last nine months.
1. I'm confident that the educators who work with our children are nearly all willing and nearly all able to take their work to a significantly higher level. When we're working on a very big change, we have to assume some will decide they don't want to make the shift, and a few will be overwhelmed or permanently hostile--but I truly believe it will only be a few.
2. We've spent years wanting teachers to switch to a very different pattern of teaching. We're asking for classrooms to be built around standards, around checking steadily to see which students are reaching the standards, and around constant adaptation to push toward every student mastering required knowledge and skills. We're asking for a lot from our teachers.
3. At times, we've acted as though explaining what's needed would make it happen. Now though, we know that incoming teachers have been reading about the key practices in their education practices for years, just as veterans have been hearing about them during PD days. The missing piece is not exposure to the ideas. If we believed that once, we cannot believe it now.
4. At times, we've clearly thought that adding carrots or sticks would be enough to get educators to apply the changes. We've tried rewards, and we've tried sanctions, and we've tried the promise-or-threat of intervention. We've talked about performance pay and suggested to parents that they bail out of weak schools. Often, we've compared all of that to the discipline of a free market, forgetting that the free market operates with lots and lots of failure: for every business that survives, the market crushes several in the dust. Again, if we once believed incentives would do the job, we can't believe that any more.
5. That's why the crucial step is changing school cultures. The culture that will transform teaching is one of professional learning communities and leadership intensely focused on instruction. That culture gives each teacher support to make the changes, including frank feedback, steady professional development, and a team of colleagues to keep sorting through what's effective and what isn't for each student.
6. The big change in culture must mainly be built at the local level, in individual schools and districts. State officials will never be the main actors.
7. Nevertheless, the state can make an important contribution. Right now, the things the Department can do quickly involve the quality of teacher evaluations, professional development, and principal evaluations, and the thing the Board can do quickly is focus a few more local boards on how deeply their districts need to change. Those things are the levers I commended to the Chairman.
8. Plenty of other improvements would also help. 185 days of instruction and 15 added days in a standard teaching contract. Teacher preparation program already focused on standards, formative assessment, data analysis, and differentiated instruction, delivered in a practicum-intensive format. Stronger entry-level salaries. Staff support to make the principalship a "do-able" job. Robust recruitment programs for teachers, teacher-leaders, and principals. I don''t mean to discount those steps--though I do think it's important to suggest the ones that can work even while the state treasury continues to be very bare.
1. I'm confident that the educators who work with our children are nearly all willing and nearly all able to take their work to a significantly higher level. When we're working on a very big change, we have to assume some will decide they don't want to make the shift, and a few will be overwhelmed or permanently hostile--but I truly believe it will only be a few.
2. We've spent years wanting teachers to switch to a very different pattern of teaching. We're asking for classrooms to be built around standards, around checking steadily to see which students are reaching the standards, and around constant adaptation to push toward every student mastering required knowledge and skills. We're asking for a lot from our teachers.
3. At times, we've acted as though explaining what's needed would make it happen. Now though, we know that incoming teachers have been reading about the key practices in their education practices for years, just as veterans have been hearing about them during PD days. The missing piece is not exposure to the ideas. If we believed that once, we cannot believe it now.
4. At times, we've clearly thought that adding carrots or sticks would be enough to get educators to apply the changes. We've tried rewards, and we've tried sanctions, and we've tried the promise-or-threat of intervention. We've talked about performance pay and suggested to parents that they bail out of weak schools. Often, we've compared all of that to the discipline of a free market, forgetting that the free market operates with lots and lots of failure: for every business that survives, the market crushes several in the dust. Again, if we once believed incentives would do the job, we can't believe that any more.
5. That's why the crucial step is changing school cultures. The culture that will transform teaching is one of professional learning communities and leadership intensely focused on instruction. That culture gives each teacher support to make the changes, including frank feedback, steady professional development, and a team of colleagues to keep sorting through what's effective and what isn't for each student.
6. The big change in culture must mainly be built at the local level, in individual schools and districts. State officials will never be the main actors.
7. Nevertheless, the state can make an important contribution. Right now, the things the Department can do quickly involve the quality of teacher evaluations, professional development, and principal evaluations, and the thing the Board can do quickly is focus a few more local boards on how deeply their districts need to change. Those things are the levers I commended to the Chairman.
8. Plenty of other improvements would also help. 185 days of instruction and 15 added days in a standard teaching contract. Teacher preparation program already focused on standards, formative assessment, data analysis, and differentiated instruction, delivered in a practicum-intensive format. Stronger entry-level salaries. Staff support to make the principalship a "do-able" job. Robust recruitment programs for teachers, teacher-leaders, and principals. I don''t mean to discount those steps--though I do think it's important to suggest the ones that can work even while the state treasury continues to be very bare.
Wednesday, February 17, 2010
Advocacy for every student, college-and-career-readiness for every student
The Missing Piece approach to parent engagement puts a high value on advocacy, setting this as the standard: "For each student, the school staff identifies and supports a parent or another adult who takes personal responsibility for understanding and speaking for each child’s learning needs." It describes a school with that commitment as having features like these:
What they want, over and over, is to get a clear commitment on what a child needs to learn and a clear commitment on the steps to make that happen and then (most importantly) follow-through on what goes down in the IEP or the notes from the meeting or the e-mail to spell out what's been discussed.
The new standards ought to make it easier for advocates to get to the specification of what a child will achieve. They're shorter, clearer, better broken down into levels of work. Using them, it should be more possible to say students will reach the standards for the grade during the school year, or begin work with a collaborating teacher next week on the two that are proving difficult, or have summer support to get on top of any standards that aren't reached by year's end.
More importantly, the new standards are custom-made for a different model of teaching. They're meant to allow every classroom to be designed around meeting the same standard for every student, but doing it by varying means and constant adjustments based on fresh information about individual progress. If that becomes the regular way of doing business, then advocates will have a much simpler job. If the school day is already organized around responding to individual needs, the advocates will only need to discuss which particular adjustments will be the best help for a particular student.
Earlier PrichBlog posts on parent engagement and the new standards are here, here, and here.
• School staff ensures every student has a parent and/or another adult who knows how to advocate, or speak up for them, regarding the student’s academic goals and individual needs.I've spent a lot of time talking with frustrated advocates for individual children: they're pretty much my favorite kind of folks.
• Most parents participate actively in student led conferences or other two-way communication about meeting their child’s individual learning needs.
• Parents report participating actively and effectively in required planning for individual learning, for example, Individual Education Plans, Individual Learning Plans, Gifted Student Plans, 504 Plans, and intervention strategies to ensure college readiness....
• School staff gives parents clear, complete information on the procedures for resolving concerns and filing complaints, and the council reviews summary data on those complaints to identify needed improvements.
• School staff ensures that parents and community members are well informed about how to become educational advocates, or how to access a trained educational advocate when needed.
• As students are identified by school staff as having disabilities or performing at the novice level, additional intentional steps are taken to ensure that parents have the option to use a trained advocate to assist them in speaking for their child’s needs.
What they want, over and over, is to get a clear commitment on what a child needs to learn and a clear commitment on the steps to make that happen and then (most importantly) follow-through on what goes down in the IEP or the notes from the meeting or the e-mail to spell out what's been discussed.
The new standards ought to make it easier for advocates to get to the specification of what a child will achieve. They're shorter, clearer, better broken down into levels of work. Using them, it should be more possible to say students will reach the standards for the grade during the school year, or begin work with a collaborating teacher next week on the two that are proving difficult, or have summer support to get on top of any standards that aren't reached by year's end.
More importantly, the new standards are custom-made for a different model of teaching. They're meant to allow every classroom to be designed around meeting the same standard for every student, but doing it by varying means and constant adjustments based on fresh information about individual progress. If that becomes the regular way of doing business, then advocates will have a much simpler job. If the school day is already organized around responding to individual needs, the advocates will only need to discuss which particular adjustments will be the best help for a particular student.
Earlier PrichBlog posts on parent engagement and the new standards are here, here, and here.
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Federal committee hears about Kentucky parent leaders' work
Kentucky's Missing Piece report on parent engagement got new attention recently, as the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions learned that:
Kentucky is the first state to adopt and codify state standards on family and community engagement. Developed by the Commissioner’s Parent Advisory Council (CPAC) these state standards for family engagement align with the state’s academic standards, and describe what practice looks like at the novice, apprentice, proficient and distinguished levels. (National PTA drew on these standards to develop their national standards.) Schools and districts in Kentucky use these standards to guide their school improvement plans and link parent involvement strategies to student achievement. When schools fail to improve student test scores two years in a row, they undergo a scholastic audit performed by a team appointed by the state education agency. The audit protocol includes a review of school practices to engage families in improving student achievement, based on the state standards.That's from a great April 22nd statement to the committee from Anne T. Henderson of the Annenberg Institute for School Reform, speaking at hearings on reauthorizing the Elementary and Secondary Education Act. Check out the complete PDF statement here. (Hat tip to Cindy Baumert)
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Engaging parents in the push to college-and-career-readiness
Kentucky is moving forward with college-and-career-readiness standards. 48 states are participating in developing those standards, but Kentucky is the first state to start the regulatory process to adopt them, and we'll be among the first to move the standards into our classrooms and our assessments.
To actually reach the standards, we'll need to add another element: sustained parent engagement. The Missing Piece of the Proficiency Puzzle (developed in 2007 by the Commissioner's Parent Advisory Council) identifies six key elements of meaningful work to engage those crucial participants:
1. Relationship-building
2. Communications
3. Decision-making
4. Advocacy
5. Learning Opportunities
6. Community Partnerships
All six elements matter, and in the coming week, I'll think out loud about how Kentucky might get started on using each one to move students toward meeting our new clearer and deeper standards.
To actually reach the standards, we'll need to add another element: sustained parent engagement. The Missing Piece of the Proficiency Puzzle (developed in 2007 by the Commissioner's Parent Advisory Council) identifies six key elements of meaningful work to engage those crucial participants:1. Relationship-building
2. Communications
3. Decision-making
4. Advocacy
5. Learning Opportunities
6. Community Partnerships
All six elements matter, and in the coming week, I'll think out loud about how Kentucky might get started on using each one to move students toward meeting our new clearer and deeper standards.
Monday, February 15, 2010
Parent learning opportunities to support college-and-career-ready standards
The Missing Piece report counts parent learning opportunities as one of the six ways schools ought to engage parents. Kentucky has committed to new college-and-career-ready standards for students, and it's time to get moving on ways for parents to learn about what's changing.
I'd suggest several steps for that effort.
Right now, spread the word about what's coming. In newsletters, PTA meetings, and elsewhere, it's time to talk up the pending change. As a parent, there are two features of the new standards that strike me as the most important. First, we will see a much more concrete statement of what their students should be able to do as they complete each level of education. Second, we can see where work at each level is heading: students who move through each level of the standards will finish high school be equipped for college-level work and ready to succeed in jobs with a future.
Soon, start designing tools for parents to explore the standards when a final edition is released:
And, this fall, make the standards central to parent activities. Our new expectations are the right centerpiece of all the start-up activities of a new academic year, from registration to home visits and open houses. They should get the spotlight at multiple school board, school council, and PTA or P.T.O. meetings.
I'd suggest several steps for that effort.
Right now, spread the word about what's coming. In newsletters, PTA meetings, and elsewhere, it's time to talk up the pending change. As a parent, there are two features of the new standards that strike me as the most important. First, we will see a much more concrete statement of what their students should be able to do as they complete each level of education. Second, we can see where work at each level is heading: students who move through each level of the standards will finish high school be equipped for college-level work and ready to succeed in jobs with a future.
Soon, start designing tools for parents to explore the standards when a final edition is released:
- For starters, the documents for each grade should be available on an accessible, widely publicized website.
- Second, examples matter. Right now, the English/language arts draft does a good job of displaying what sort of work students should be able to read at each level. The mathematics draft, though, could use clearer illustrations of the work students should master. If those examples are not built into the final edition, expert teachers should construct them quickly.
- Third, organize it all as activities that can work at PTA meetings, school socials, and other events, and as displays that can catch a parent's eye on the way into the building. Puzzles, checklists, posters, and videos can all be ways to draw parents into the discussion..
And, this fall, make the standards central to parent activities. Our new expectations are the right centerpiece of all the start-up activities of a new academic year, from registration to home visits and open houses. They should get the spotlight at multiple school board, school council, and PTA or P.T.O. meetings.
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
A manifesto of lesser ideas
Sunday, the superintendents of some of the nation's largest districts, including New York City and Washington, DC, published a manifesto on "How to fix our schools." I've read it four times, and slept on it for three nights, and I still think it's more wrong than right.
The authors are surely sincere in their desire for school systems that deliver much more for students, and they're certainly right that laying off strong teachers to keep weak ones is bad practice. Likewise, better use of better technology, closer analysis of important student data, and a focus on learning results rather than seat time in class are all good ideas.
What's missing, though, is any serious discussion of the changes within schools that strengthen individual teachers. There's no hint of professional learning communities here. There's no whisper of building the collaborative cultures needed to teach in the ways that actually raise performance and shrink achievement gaps. There's concern about removing teachers who are hopeless, but no matching intensity about building up the much larger group of teachers who can and should do the main work ahead. The core understanding that the big learning change happens with teams of teachers just isn't there.
That missing element is the essential bridge between education ideas proven in tiny studies and education changes that happen on a scale large enough to change our future.
Add that piece, and American education can reach for historic success.
Leave it out, and we can count on tiny advances, tiny retreats, and an overall legacy of stagnation.
The manifesto's authors left out what matters most.
The authors are surely sincere in their desire for school systems that deliver much more for students, and they're certainly right that laying off strong teachers to keep weak ones is bad practice. Likewise, better use of better technology, closer analysis of important student data, and a focus on learning results rather than seat time in class are all good ideas.
What's missing, though, is any serious discussion of the changes within schools that strengthen individual teachers. There's no hint of professional learning communities here. There's no whisper of building the collaborative cultures needed to teach in the ways that actually raise performance and shrink achievement gaps. There's concern about removing teachers who are hopeless, but no matching intensity about building up the much larger group of teachers who can and should do the main work ahead. The core understanding that the big learning change happens with teams of teachers just isn't there.
That missing element is the essential bridge between education ideas proven in tiny studies and education changes that happen on a scale large enough to change our future.
Add that piece, and American education can reach for historic success.
Leave it out, and we can count on tiny advances, tiny retreats, and an overall legacy of stagnation.
The manifesto's authors left out what matters most.
Monday, May 18, 2009
SB 1 and CPE discussions [Updated]
Some of Senate Bill 1's greatest potential comes from the commitment to align college expectations and P-12 standards, with the Council on Postsecondary Education as a full partner in making that happen. So far, that work is not getting a very high profile at CPE meetings.
SB 1 didn't get distinct attention in the agenda or minutes of CPE's May 4-5 retreat and isn't scheduled for substantial discussion on the agenda of CPE's May 22 meeting. For May 22, President King's "Report to the Council" does include one paragraph:
Missing, though, is one of SB 1's major requirements:
Update: a commenter has alerted me that SB 1 (as I downloaded it shortly after passage contained a typo.) In the revised version now available from the LRC, the deadlines read this way: "All core academic standards for mathematics and reading in introductory courses shall be completed by December 15, 2010 with a target completion date of December 15, 2009 for the mathematics standards." That gives postsecondary more time for this important work, and is very helpful to know!
Notes: The May 4-5 agenda is here. The May 22 agenda is here, and includes downloadable versions of the May 4-5 minutes and the President's Report. Senate Bill 1 is available here: click on the highlighted phrase "SB 1" to download the whole bill.
SB 1 didn't get distinct attention in the agenda or minutes of CPE's May 4-5 retreat and isn't scheduled for substantial discussion on the agenda of CPE's May 22 meeting. For May 22, President King's "Report to the Council" does include one paragraph:
Senate Bill 1 is a significant piece of education legislation that revises the assessment and accountability system for K-12 education in Kentucky. The bill calls on the Department of Education, in collaboration with the Council on Postsecondary Education, to plan and implement a process for revising academic content standards to increase the rigor and focus the content of K-12 education. Working collaboratively, staff members from the two agencies developed a comprehensive process to revise standards in key content areas. A planning process also was developed to reduce college remediation rates and increase graduation rates of postsecondary students with developmental education needs. The next step in SB 1 implementation is to review the current systemwide public postsecondary placement policy in English and mathematics and, working with institutional representatives and KDE, to determine whether revisions are needed in those content standards. A copy of the comprehensive revision process is included in the appendix to this meeting agenda book.That may be enough to invite greater discussion.
Missing, though, is one of SB 1's major requirements:
Within thirty days from the effective date of this Act, each postsecondary education institution shall plan and implement a process to develop core academic content standards for reading and mathematics for introductory courses in the public postsecondary education institutions.That thirty day requirement hit on April 24, and the bill follows up by saying that "All core academic standards for mathematics and reading in introductory courses shall be completed by December 15, 2009 ." In the CPE documents, I can't get any sense of how that work will proceed, and I admit to great curiosity about it.
Update: a commenter has alerted me that SB 1 (as I downloaded it shortly after passage contained a typo.) In the revised version now available from the LRC, the deadlines read this way: "All core academic standards for mathematics and reading in introductory courses shall be completed by December 15, 2010 with a target completion date of December 15, 2009 for the mathematics standards." That gives postsecondary more time for this important work, and is very helpful to know!
Notes: The May 4-5 agenda is here. The May 22 agenda is here, and includes downloadable versions of the May 4-5 minutes and the President's Report. Senate Bill 1 is available here: click on the highlighted phrase "SB 1" to download the whole bill.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




